İçeriğe geç

Bölüm 1: Part One: The Water LineBirinci Bölüm: Su Çizgisi

Bu bölüm henüz Turkish dilinde mevcut değil. Çevirmek ve herkese açmak için giriş yap.

1The creek was low for August, and Jessie Pritchard decided to take that as a sign.

She sat on the sycamore root where she always sat and worked her shoes off, heel against toe, which Granny June had told her a hundred times broke down the backs. They had been white once. Three summers on the creek path had turned them the color of sweet tea, and the left one had a hole over the little toe that she’d quit seeing. She kept her socks on. The rocks on the bottom were slick as a pew and she was not stupid.

Up the hill the kitchen light was on. Travis’s truck sat nosed against the porch steps with the driver’s door hanging open and the dome light burning, because he had spent twenty minutes before supper hunting through the cab and slamming things. He hadn’t found it. She knew he hadn’t, because it was folded in fourths and flattened in the back pocket of her jeans, and because her arm, up above the elbow where the sleeve covered it, still held the shape of his hand.

She didn’t look at the truck long.

Across the water, the woman was waiting.

She had been there the last three evenings, and before that, off and on, since school let out. A yellow housedress with little brown flowers on it. A dress out of the Sears catalog, Granny June had said, the one time Jessie described it, and then Granny June had set down her bean pan and told her to hush and never say it again in that house. The woman wore her hair pinned up off her neck. Her feet were bare on the far rocks. She held something wrapped in a dish towel against her hip.

“Jessie,” the woman said. Not loud. The creek should have swallowed it and didn’t. “Jessie, honey. It’s not deep.”

It wasn’t. Jessie had walked it a hundred times when she was little, before she understood the rule, back when the rule was just another thing grown people did, like tithing or voting. Knee-deep in the middle. Thigh-deep after a hard rain.

“I’m just gonna look,” Jessie said, to nobody, and stood up with her shoes in her hand.

The screen door banged up at the house.

“Jess!” Owen. Nine years old, built like a fence post, with a voice that carried to Tennessee. “Mama says supper! Travis says get up here!”

She stepped in.

The cold went up her shins like it had someplace to be. In August that creek ran warm as dishwater. This was spring cold, straight out of the rock, cold enough to make her back teeth hurt, and she kept walking.

“Jessie!” Higher now. Cracking. “You ain’t supposed to!”

She didn’t turn around. On the far bank the woman lifted a corner of the dish towel, and the smell came over the water: butter, and a little scorch on the bottom. That was how Granny June’s biscuits used to come out, before her hands quit. Nobody’s came out like that anymore.2Daniel Rusk had been sheriff of Blackwater County for eleven years and a deputy for eighteen before that, and in all that time he had learned you could tell most of what you needed about a family by who answered the door.

At the Pritchard place, Travis Cobb answered it.

“She’s done this before,” Travis said, before Daniel had his hat off. “Spent the night at that Shook girl’s and didn’t call. Spent two nights one time. Renee gets worked up.”

“Morning, Travis.”

“I’m just telling you. So you know what you’re dealing with.”

Travis was a big man going soft in the middle, forty or so, with a Tennessee Vols cap and a habit of standing in doorways so you had to talk to him first. He had married Renee Pritchard four years ago and moved into her granddaddy’s house, and in four years he had put a satellite dish on the roof and gotten himself arrested once in Cocke County for something the Tennessee people had been vague about on the phone. Daniel had not formed an opinion of him yet. He was working on it.

“I’d like to talk to Renee.”

“She’s laying down.”

“I’ll wait.”

Travis looked at him a while. Then he stepped back, but not all the way, so Daniel had to turn his shoulders to get by.

Renee was not laying down. She was at the kitchen table in yesterday’s work shirt from the Dollar General in Bryson Gap, the name tag still pinned on, with a cordless phone in front of her and both hands flat on either side of it. Her eyes had swollen from a day and a half of trying not to cry and losing.

“Sheriff.”

“Renee.” He took the chair across from her. Somebody had cleaned the kitchen. Too clean for a house with a missing child in it. The dish drainer was empty and the dish towel was folded in thirds over the oven handle. “When’d you see her last?”

“Supper. Thursday.” She turned the phone a quarter turn. “She didn’t come up for supper. Owen went and hollered for her.”

“That was Thursday.”

“Yes sir.”

It was Saturday morning. Daniel didn’t say anything about that. He let the number sit on the table between them next to the phone, and Renee looked at it like a bill she couldn’t pay.

“Travis said she’d come back,” she said. “Said she was mad about something and she’d sleep it off at a friend’s. I wanted to call Thursday night. I wanted to call Friday.”

“She was gonna come home,” Travis said from the doorway. “Every time before, she come home.”

“How many times before?” Daniel asked.

Travis opened his mouth.

“Twice,” Renee said. “And she called both times. She called.”

Daniel wrote that down. Called both times. He wrote it in the little spiral notebook he’d been buying at the Ingles in the same green cover since 1997, partly because he liked them and partly because a green notebook on a kitchen table made people tell you things a phone never would. Nobody had ever told him that. He had worked it out.

“What was she mad about?”

Renee’s hands came together on the table. “Teenager stuff.”

“Like what?”

“She’s sixteen, Sheriff.” Travis again. “Like everything.”

Daniel let that go too. He asked for the friends’ names and wrote them down. He asked about a boyfriend. There was a boy at the high school, a Ledford, that Renee didn’t approve of and Jessie hadn’t seen since June. He asked for a recent photograph, and Renee went to the refrigerator and took down a school picture from under a magnet shaped like a peach, and Daniel looked at a girl with her mother’s mouth and somebody else’s eyes, gray and level, looking at the camera like she’d been told to smile and decided against it.

“Can I keep this?”

“I got more.”

“You searched?”

“Since Thursday night. Me and Travis and my cousins and Pastor Pike’s people. Up the ridge and all down Creek Road to the highway.” Renee touched the phone again. “The barn. The well house.”

“All right,” Daniel said. “I’m going to walk around some.”


The Pritchard place sat in a bowl of land where Shoal Creek bent around a hayfield and doubled back on itself. The house was on the rise, the barn below it, and below the barn the field ran down to the water and stopped. On the far side the land went up steep into hardwood and rhododendron, Bell timber, mostly, though the Pritchards had held onto twenty acres over there since before anybody bothered to write it down.

He could see where the family had searched. People who search leave a mess. There were trampled lanes through the tall grass at the edge of the woods, boot prints in the red mud up the old skid road, a Mountain Dew can on a fence post, a pink survey ribbon somebody had tied on a dogwood so they’d know they’d checked it. Daniel followed the lanes. They went up. They went around the barn twice.

None of them went down to the creek.

He stood at the bottom of the field and looked. The bush hog had been run right up to ten feet of the bank and stopped there, square, like a property line. Below that the grass was knee-high and unbroken. Nobody had walked it. Not Thursday night, and not this morning with three dozen people and a preacher.

He thought about that for a while.

Two days of rain had come through since Thursday. The creek was up some, brown and loud over the shoals, and the sycamore on the near bank had a ring of drift around its roots. He walked down to it. The grass tore at his uniform pants and soaked them to the knee. On the sycamore root, where you would sit if you were a girl who wanted to sit by the water, there was nothing at all.

When he came back up, there was an old woman in a wheelchair on the porch.

He knew her. Everybody in Blackwater knew June Pritchard, same as they knew the curve on 28 where the Pentecostals put up the white crosses. She had to be close to ninety. She sat in a wheelchair with a blanket over her knees and a bowl of half-runner beans in her lap, and she was stringing them without looking at them, because she was looking at the creek.

“Miss June.”

“Daniel Rusk.” She snapped a bean. “You’ve got grass seed all over you.”

“Yes ma’am.”

“You went down there.”

“Yes ma’am.”

She snapped another bean and dropped the ends over the porch rail into the hydrangeas. She didn’t say anything else. She didn’t need to. Daniel had been raised in this county and the silence of an old woman on a porch was a language he had learned before he could read.

There was a boy sitting on the top step with his knees up under his chin, a skinny towhead in a Spider-Man shirt too small for him. Owen. He was watching Daniel’s gun belt with professional interest.

“You’re Owen.”

“Yeah.”

“You’re the one went and hollered for her.”

Owen nodded.

“Where was she?”

Owen looked at his great-grandmother. June went on snapping beans.

“At the creek,” Owen said.

“Doing what?”

The boy picked at a scab on his knee. “She went to the lady.”

The beans stopped.

“What lady’s that?” Daniel asked.

“The creek lady. Across.”

“Owen.” Renee in the screen door, fast. “Owen, go on in and get your shoes on.”

“I got my shoes on.”

“Then go get your other shoes on.”

He went. Renee stood holding the screen door with the flat of her hand and did not look at the creek, and did not look at Daniel. It was a lot of not looking for one woman on one porch.

“He watches stuff on the tablet,” Travis said, coming up behind her. “YouTube. Them ghost hunter fellas. Kid’s nine.”

“Sure,” Daniel said.

He walked to his Tahoe. It was hot already, the sun up over Frog Mountain and the cicadas going, and the cab of the Tahoe smelled like coffee and the vinyl of the seats. He sat with the door open and wrote in the green notebook. Didn’t search creek. June watching water. Owen: “the lady.” Across.

Then he wrote one more line and looked at it.

No dog.

There was not a farm on Creek Road without a dog on it. There wasn’t a farm in the county. You drove into a man’s yard in Blackwater and something came out from under the porch and announced you, and you sat in your truck until somebody called it off. He had been at the Pritchard place for an hour and nothing had barked.

His radio crackled.

“Sheriff.” Bev Tolley at dispatch, who had been at dispatch since Daniel was a rookie and would be at dispatch, he suspected, after the sun burned out. “You still on Creek Road?”

“Still here.”

“DA’s office called. They’ve requested the SBI on the Pritchard girl, on account of the stepdaddy’s record and her being a juvenile. Agent’s already on her way. Ought to be there inside the hour.”

Daniel looked at the radio for a while.

“The DA requested.”

“That’s what they told me, honey.”

“Did they say why the DA didn’t call the sheriff before he called Raleigh?”

“They did not.” Bev let that sit just long enough. “Want me to call and ask?”

“No,” Daniel said. “No, I’ll wait on her.”3She came in a gray Charger with state plates and a dent in the rear quarter panel that somebody had tried to buff out and given up on. She parked behind the Tahoe, not beside it, and she got out with a field bag over one shoulder and a tablet in her hand and looked the house over like a surveyor walking a lot. Early thirties. Dark hair pulled back hard. A pale scar ran through her left eyebrow and split it in two, and she hadn’t done a thing to hide it.

“Sheriff Rusk?”

“That’s me.”

“Special Agent Lena Mercer, State Bureau of Investigation.” She offered her hand. “I appreciate the cooperation.”

Daniel had his notebook open. He’d been writing a phone number, Renee’s cousin in Sylva, and the pen kept going after she said her name. It went off the end of the number and down off the line and made a long blue tail across the bottom of the page. He looked at it. He closed the notebook.

“Mercer,” he said.

“That’s right.”

“You’re out of the Asheville office?”

“Raleigh. I was in Asheville this week on something else.” She said it fast and even. “It was convenient.”

He shook her hand. It was cool and dry and she let go first.

“Well,” he said. “You’re in Blackwater now.”

“So I gather.” She glanced at the porch, where June had gone back to the beans and Travis had come out to stand on the top step with his arms folded. “That’s the stepfather.”

“Travis Cobb.”

“Assault on a household member, Cocke County, Tennessee, 2019. Pled down to simple. The victim was the ex-wife.” She was reading it off the tablet without looking at the tablet. “No priors in North Carolina. Married the mother in 2022.”

“You’ve done your homework.”

“It was a long drive.” She tucked the tablet under her arm. “What have you got?”

He told her. Thursday supper. The call that didn’t come for a day and a half. The searchers, the ridge, the barn. He told her about Owen and the creek lady, and he told her about the dog, and he watched her decide which of those things went in her file and which ones didn’t. The dog went in. The lady didn’t.

“I’ll want phone records,” she said. “Hers and his. Her social media, whatever she’s on. I’ll want to talk to the mother alone, without him in the doorway. And I’ll want a timeline from every adult on this property from five p.m. Thursday on.”

“All right.”

“And I’ll want him somewhere I can see him.”

“He’s not going anywhere.”

“People go places, Sheriff.” She was already walking toward the house. “That’s my whole job.”

Daniel watched her go up the steps. Travis unfolded his arms and stepped into the doorway to block it, same as he’d blocked it for Daniel, and Lena Mercer walked directly at him at the same speed she’d been walking, until it was move or get walked into. He moved.

Daniel stood in the yard a minute longer. Then he took his phone out of his shirt pocket and went down the contacts to a number he had not called in years, a retired SBI supervisor named Hal Brookshire who had worked out of the Asheville office in the early 2000s and now lived on a golf course outside Hendersonville and sent Christmas cards with his grandkids on them. He looked at the number. He put the phone back.

He didn’t need to call Hal. He knew who she was.

Lena got Travis out of the house by asking him to drive to the Shook place and bring the Shook girl back for a statement. It was a reasonable request and it would take him forty minutes, and he knew both of those things, and he went anyway because there was no way to refuse it that wouldn’t sound like refusing.

When the truck was gone she sat down across from Renee at the kitchen table, in the chair Daniel had sat in that morning. Daniel leaned on the counter by the empty dish drainer and kept his mouth shut. He had been told, in so many words, that he was welcome to observe.

“Thursday,” Lena said. “Before supper. Tell me about the afternoon.”

“She was home from her shift at the Dairy Bar. Three or so.” Renee turned the cordless phone a quarter turn. “She was in her room.”

“The whole afternoon?”

“Mostly.”

“Where else?”

Renee looked at the window over the sink. From that window you could see the yard, and Travis’s parking spot by the porch steps, and the oil stain where his truck usually sat.

“She was out in the yard a while.”

“Doing what?”

“I don’t know. Out there.”

“Mrs. Pritchard.”

“Cobb,” Renee said. “It’s Cobb now.”

Lena wrote that down, though she already knew it. “Mrs. Cobb. Was Jessie in Travis’s truck on Thursday?”

The phone stopped turning.

“She might have been,” Renee said. “She borrows his charger.”

“Did they argue?”

“They argue every day. She’s sixteen.”

“About the truck?”

“He don’t like her in it. He’s funny about that truck.” Renee got up. She went to the coffee maker and poured a cup she didn’t drink, and when she reached up into the cabinet for the sugar the sleeve of her work shirt slid back from her wrist, and Daniel saw the bruise. It ran around the wrist bone like a bracelet, going yellow at the edges and green in the middle, four or five days old. She pulled the cuff down with her other hand without looking at it. Lena was writing. She didn’t see. Daniel didn’t say anything, and he would think about that later, more than once.

“Has Travis ever hurt Jessie?” Lena asked.

Renee came back to the table with the coffee and set it down.

“He’s never laid a hand on that child,” she said. “He loves her. He’s raised her four years like she was his. He bought her that phone.”

“I asked if he’d hurt her.”

“And I told you.”

They sat there. Up on the second floor a television came on, cartoons, loud, and then somebody turned it down.

Renee looked past Lena at Daniel, and something in her face changed, and when she spoke again it was to him.

“You went down to the water this morning.”

“I did.”

“Did you go over?”

“No.”

She nodded slowly. She looked at Lena then, really looked at her for the first time, the hard ponytail and the scar through the eyebrow, like one woman sizing up another in a grocery line.

“Don’t you let her go over there,” Renee said to Daniel.

“Mrs. Cobb,” Lena said, “I’ll go where the evidence goes.”

“My aunt was about your age when she went over,” Renee said. “Younger.” She stood up, and took the coffee she hadn’t drunk to the sink, and poured it out, and rinsed the cup, and set it upside down in the empty drainer. “I’ve got to see about Owen.”

She went upstairs. Lena sat looking at the spot where she’d been.

“Her aunt,” Lena said.

“Della,” Daniel said. “That’s the 1978 file.”

“You said there was a file. You didn’t say there was an aunt.”

“You didn’t ask.”

She closed her notebook. “I’m getting a warrant for that truck,” she said.4Cody Voss brought the dogs at three.

He had two of them in the back of his pickup, a bluetick named Dolly and a redbone named Hank, and he let them down off the tailgate one at a time, lifting them under the chest like sacks of feed. Cody was twenty-six and had been running dogs since he was eight. His great-granddaddy had run dogs for the county back when there were still bears enough in these mountains to make a living at it. The Vosses had been finding things in these woods for a hundred years, people mostly said, and there were a few old-timers who said the Vosses had a lot of practice at knowing where not to look. Daniel had never asked what they meant.

“What you got for scent?” Cody asked.

Renee brought a pillowcase in a Walmart bag. Cody opened it under each dog’s nose and let them work it, talking low to them the whole time, sweet nonsense, that’s it, that’s my girl, you get it, you got it, and then he unclipped the leads.

Lena stood next to Daniel at the top of the field with her arms crossed.

“Do these usually work?”

“Cody’s do.”

Dolly went off the porch like she’d been shot out of something. She circled the yard once with her nose in the grass and Hank behind her. Then she bawled, a long rising note that bounced off the far ridge and came back, and the two of them went straight down the hayfield, past the barn, through the bush-hogged stubble and into the tall grass at the bottom, and they did not slow down until they hit the creek bank.

And then they stopped.

Daniel had seen dogs lose a scent. They cast around. They went in circles, noses down, frustrated, working. These dogs did not cast. They stood at the water’s edge with their front feet on the last dry rock and their tails down, and Dolly whined, a high thin sound like a hinge, and Hank backed up two steps and sat down in the mud.

Cody walked down. Daniel and Lena followed.

“Go on,” Cody said to the dogs. “Go on over, Doll. Hunt it up.”

Dolly looked at him. She looked at the water. She put one foot in it and took it right back out and shook it like a cat.

“She don’t like it,” Cody said.

“It’s a foot of water,” Lena said.

“Yes ma’am.”

“So she lost the scent at the water. The girl went in the creek. Either she walked it or she crossed it.” Lena looked up and down the bank. “Can they pick it back up on the other side?”

“They won’t cross.”

“Why not?”

Cody squatted and scratched Dolly behind the ears. He didn’t look at Lena. He looked at Daniel, and Daniel understood that Cody Voss was about to say something to the sheriff that he would not say to a stranger, and would not say twice.

“Never would here,” Cody said. “Not my daddy’s dogs neither. Not on this bend.” He stood up and clipped the leads back on. “I’ll bring ’em around by the bridge on Bell Road if you want. Come at it from the far side. But they won’t go over here.”

He walked the dogs back up the field. They went with him gladly. Hank kept looking back over his shoulder at the water.

Lena watched them go. Then she turned to Daniel.

“Explain that to me.”

“I can’t.”

“Try.”

He looked at the far bank. The rhododendron came down nearly to the water over there, dark and glossy, and the shade under it at three in the afternoon was as deep as nine at night.

“The Pritchards don’t go over this water,” he said. “They haven’t since before I was born. I don’t know all of why. I know they’ll walk two miles around by the bridge to get to their own land on the other side. I know June Pritchard hasn’t set foot on that bank since 1978. And I know nobody that searched for that girl since Thursday came within ten feet of this creek, and that includes her mother.”

“Because of a superstition.”

“Because of something.”

“Sheriff.” She said it like a teacher about to correct a child. “With respect. I’ve worked in counties like this. Every one of them has something the families don’t talk about, and every one of them has a creek or a bridge where somebody’s grandmother saw a light. It’s local color. I don’t doubt they believe it.” She looked back at the water. “But a sixteen-year-old girl went missing with a stepfather in the house who has an assault conviction and who talked her mother out of calling the police for thirty-six hours. I’ve seen that a hundred times. I’ve never once seen it turn out to be a ghost.”

“I didn’t say it wasn’t.”

“Then we agree.” She took out her phone. “I’m getting a state search team in here tomorrow at first light. Grid search on the far side, the whole drainage. Divers if we need them.”

“All right.”

“And I want to see the cab of his truck.”

Daniel didn’t argue. She was right about the truck. She was right about the thirty-six hours. She was right about most of it, as far as it went, and he had spent twenty-nine years in this county learning how far most things went before they stopped.

He looked once more at the far bank, at the place under the rhododendron where the shade was deepest. Nothing there. A wren. A shine of wet rock.

He went back up the field.


It was after eleven when he got home.

The house was on Hickory Knob, a brick ranch his daddy had built in 1971 and his mama had died in, and Carrie had done everything to it she could think of in twenty-two years and it was still his daddy’s house. The porch light was on. That was something. Some nights it wasn’t.

He let himself in through the kitchen. There was a plate in the microwave under a paper towel, a pork chop and some green beans and half a baked potato, and a note on the counter in Carrie’s slanting hand. Mom called. Call her. Don’t forget Brandon’s birthday Sunday. Brandon was her sister’s boy. He was turning fourteen or fifteen. Daniel could not have told you which under oath.

He ate the pork chop cold, standing at the counter. He didn’t bother with the microwave. He’d been married long enough to know that heating up a plate at eleven-thirty made a sound you could hear from the bedroom, and that the sound started a conversation, and he didn’t have it in him tonight.

He rinsed the plate. He set it in the drainer. He walked down the hall, and as he passed the closed door of the back bedroom he put his hand flat on it for a second without stopping. He had no idea he did it. Carrie had told him once, years ago, and he hadn’t believed her.

In their bedroom, Carrie was asleep on her side with her back to his half of the bed. She slept that way now. She had slept that way for a while, long enough that he had stopped noticing when it started.

He sat on the edge of the mattress to take his boots off, and she didn’t move, and he sat there a while with one boot in his hand.5The state team was due at seven. At six-fifteen Lena Mercer was standing at the bottom of the Pritchard hayfield in rubber knee boots she’d bought at the Tractor Supply in Bryson Gap, which Daniel knew because the tag was still zip-tied to the left one.

He’d come early because he had a feeling she would.

“Morning,” he said.

“I’m going over.”

“The team’ll be here in forty-five minutes.”

“And then there’ll be thirty people walking all over that bank.” She was looking at the water. It had come down overnight. It ran clear and quiet over the shoals now, and you could see every stone on the bottom, gold and brown and green with moss. “I want to see it before they do.”

He didn’t say anything. She took that as agreement, which it wasn’t, exactly.

She stepped in.

Daniel watched her. She walked it slow, feeling for footing, her arms out a little for balance. Knee-deep at the middle. The current pulled at her boots and she leaned into it. Nothing happened. The water went around her, and a crow went over, and up on the porch June Pritchard sat in her wheelchair in the gray light with a quilt over her knees, watching. Daniel hadn’t seen her come out. He didn’t know how long she’d been there.

Lena reached the far bank, climbed the rocks, and stopped.

“Sheriff.”

He looked at the water.

He had grown up in this county. He had waded every creek in it, fished most of them, pulled two drowned men out of the Blackwater River and one little girl out of Panther Creek who lived. He had stood at the edge of a hundred streams. He stood at the edge of this one, and his boots did not move, and he stood there long enough that the agent on the other side turned around to see what was taking him.

He stepped in.

It was cold. Spring cold, rock cold. In August. It came through his boots and his socks and closed around his ankles like hands, and he kept his eyes on the far bank and he did not stop, and when he climbed out on the other side his feet were numb and his heart was going like he’d run up the field.

Lena didn’t notice. She was looking down.

On a flat gray rock at the top of the bank, set side by side with the toes pointed at the creek, were a pair of girl’s sneakers. White once. The color of sweet tea now. The left one had a hole over the little toe.

They were dry.

Daniel crouched beside them. He didn’t touch them. He looked at the rock under them, which was dry, and the rock next to them, which was dark with dew, and the moss on the bank, which squished under his boot heel and leaked water. Two days of rain. A night of dew. And these shoes sat there dry as if somebody had set them down five minutes ago, carefully, toes to the water, like shoes left outside a door somebody meant to come back through.

“They’ve been moved,” Lena said. “Somebody put them here after the rain.”

“Maybe.”

“There’s no maybe. They’re dry.”

“I can see they’re dry.”

She was taking photographs. Wide, then close, with an evidence ruler she’d fished out of the field bag. She was good at it. Daniel watched her hands and thought that her hands were steady, and then thought that they weren’t quite, not at the very end when she lowered the camera, and then thought it was none of his business.

“Here,” she said.

Beside the right shoe, half under it, was a ribbon. A hair ribbon, the old-fashioned kind, grosgrain, a little frayed at one end. Yellow, with small orange daisies printed on it. The yellow had gone soft and the daisies had faded nearly white. A girl would have tied her hair up with it in a kitchen with an avocado-green refrigerator.

Daniel looked at it a long time.

“That’s not hers,” he said.

“How do you know?”

“Because nobody’s sold a ribbon like that in forty years.”

Lena bagged it. She bagged the shoes. She wrote on the bags in black marker in neat block capitals and signed across the seals, and when she was done she stood up and looked into the woods behind the rock, where the rhododendron closed over a path that wasn’t quite a path.

“Somebody brought her over here,” she said. “Or followed her. She took off her shoes to cross, and either she put them down and walked up into those woods on her own, or somebody else put them down after.” She looked at Daniel. “Either way, somebody came back. After the rain. And they knew exactly where to leave them so we’d find them.”

“Could be.”

“You don’t think so.”

He looked back across the water at the porch. June Pritchard had not moved.

“I think,” Daniel said, “we ought to go back over before your team gets here and starts asking why the sheriff’s standing on this bank with his feet wet.”6The Quik Stop at the junction of Creek Road and Highway 28 had one camera that worked, and it pointed at the pumps.

Lena had requested the footage at nine Saturday night. By noon Sunday she was in the sheriff’s office conference room with a laptop open on the table, a bottle of Cheerwine she hadn’t touched, and a still image frozen on the screen. A black Silverado at pump three. A man in a ball cap filling it. Time stamp: 2:07 a.m., Friday.

“That’s his truck,” Daniel said.

“That’s his truck. And that’s him.” She tapped the screen. “He told me, and he told you, and he told the deputy who took the initial report, that he was home in bed by eleven Thursday night and didn’t wake up until six.”

“He told me that.”

“I’d like to know where he was going at two in the morning with a full tank.”

Coy Hargrove leaned in the doorway with his thumbs in his belt. Coy was the judge’s nephew and had come on as a deputy three years ago, and he had the Hargrove gift of standing in a room like he had paid for it.

“Could’ve been going anywhere,” Coy said. “Man couldn’t sleep. Girl’s missing. He goes driving around looking.”

“Then why lie about it?” Lena asked.

Coy shrugged. “Folks lie to the law. Doesn’t mean they did anything.”

“It does in my experience.”

“Well, ma’am,” Coy said, “this ain’t Raleigh.”

Daniel looked at Coy until Coy found a reason to go see about something at the front desk.

“Bring him in,” Lena said. “Voluntary. I want to ask him about this before he finds out we have it.”


Travis came in at two in a clean shirt with his hair wet-combed, like a man going to church or court, and sat across from Lena in the interview room with his hands folded on the table. Daniel took the corner chair by the door. It was his office and his chair, and he let her run it.

She ran it well. She asked him about Thursday supper and let him tell it, and he told it the same as before. She asked about Jessie’s friends and he named them. She asked him about the Shook girl and the two nights Jessie had stayed out before, and Travis warmed up some, told a story about the second time, how they’d found her asleep in the hayloft and how mad Renee had been, how he’d had to calm Renee down.

“You’re close with her,” Lena said. “Jessie.”

“I try to be. She don’t make it easy. She’s got her daddy’s temper.”

“Where’s her daddy?”

“Florida. Somewhere. He don’t call.” Travis turned his hands over on the table. “I’m the one that’s there.”

“And Thursday night you were there.”

“All night.”

“In bed by eleven.”

“Yes ma’am.”

“Didn’t get up.”

“Slept like a rock.” He smiled a little. “Renee’ll tell you. I snore.”

Lena turned the laptop around.

Travis looked at it. He looked at it longer than he needed to. He was working something out, and Daniel watched him work it, and watched him land on it, and watched his shoulders come down a quarter inch.

“Okay,” Travis said. “Okay, I went out. I couldn’t sleep. I went driving around looking for her. I didn’t say because Renee didn’t know I’d gone, and I didn’t want her thinking…” He opened his hands. “I don’t know. I didn’t want her thinking.”

“Thinking what?”

“That I was out looking. That I was worried. She was already worried enough.”

“Where’d you drive?”

“Around. Up Creek Road. Over to Bryson Gap and back. Past the Shook place.”

“At two in the morning.”

“I said I couldn’t sleep.”

Lena nodded like that was reasonable. She wrote something down. She turned a page in her legal pad. And then she said, in the voice she’d use for the weather, “What happened to your arm?”

He looked down. His sleeves were buttoned at the wrist, but when he’d turned his hands over on the table the left cuff had ridden up. Four scratches on the inside of the forearm. Parallel. Scabbed, but not old. Two or three days.

Travis pulled the cuff down.

“Dog,” he said.

The room went quiet.

Lena didn’t say anything. She’d heard what Daniel heard; he could see it go into her face and stay there. But she didn’t know yet how much it weighed, and she was smart enough to wait.

Daniel leaned forward in the corner chair, and the chair creaked, and Travis turned to look at him.

“Y’all don’t have a dog, Travis.”

Travis looked at him a long time.

“Neighbor’s dog,” he said. “Over at the Raines place. Big ol’ shepherd. I was helping Hollis with his gate.”

“When?”

“Wednesday.”

“I’ll ask Hollis,” Daniel said.

“You do that.”

Travis stood up. He took his time about it. He wanted them to watch.

“Am I under arrest?”

“No,” Lena said.

“Then I’m gonna go home to my wife.”

He went. Daniel heard him say something to Bev at the front desk, and heard Bev not answer, and heard the glass door swing shut.7They had it out in the parking lot, which in Blackwater was the same as having it out on the courthouse lawn.

“He lied about the drive,” Lena said. “He lied about the scratches. He has a conviction for assaulting a member of his household and a stepdaughter who’s been missing for three days. I could get a magistrate to sign off on a warrant for that truck in an hour and I could hold him for twenty-four on obstruction while we tear it apart.”

“You could.”

“Then why are you looking at me like that?”

“Like what?”

“Like I’m a tourist.”

Daniel leaned against the Tahoe. The asphalt was soft with heat and smelled like tar. Across the street, two old men on the bench in front of Haskett’s Hardware had stopped talking and were watching them with the open interest of men who had been retired a long time.

“You’ll get the truck,” he said. “Get the warrant. Search it. You should. But you hold him on obstruction for lying about a drive he’s already admitted to, and the DA’ll cut him loose by suppertime tomorrow, and he’ll go home and sit on that porch and every Cobb and half the Pritchards in this county will decide the state came in and railroaded a grieving stepdaddy, and the next time you need one of them to tell you something, they won’t.”

“I don’t care what they decide.”

“I know you don’t. I do. I have to live here.”

“And I have to find a sixteen-year-old girl.” She was very still when she was angry, he noticed. Some people get loud. She went still, like something in tall grass. “How long have you known Travis Cobb, Sheriff?”

“Four years. About.”

“Go to church with his people?”

“He doesn’t go to church.”

“Hunt with his cousins? Owe somebody in that family a favor? Have a deputy who’s married to one?”

Daniel looked at her. She looked back. Over at the hardware store, one of the old men leaned over and said something to the other one and the other one laughed.

“You don’t have enough,” Daniel said. “That’s all. You don’t have enough yet. Scratches and a lie. I’ve got the same bad feeling you do. I had it before you got here. But you don’t have a girl, and you don’t have a place he put her. Get the truck. Get her phone records. Find me one thing he can’t explain, and I’ll put the cuffs on him myself in front of God and the Baptist church.”

She didn’t say anything for a while.

“You said there was a file,” she said finally. “From 1978.”

“There’s a file.”

“You said something happened on that creek in 1978. You didn’t say what.”

“A girl went missing.”

“From that family.”

“From that family.”

“I want to see the file.”

“It’s at my house.”

That stopped her. “Why is a 1978 case file at your house?”

“Because I keep it there,” Daniel said. “Come by tonight. After eight.”


Carrie was working a twelve at the hospital, seven to seven. The house was dark when he got there, and he turned on every light in the kitchen and the living room and stood looking at them, and then he made a pot of coffee he didn’t want so there’d be something to offer.

Lena knocked at eight-fifteen. She’d changed out of the rubber boots and into running shoes. She stood in the kitchen and looked at the refrigerator, which had a magnet calendar from Blue Ridge Electric and a photograph of Carrie and her sister at Myrtle Beach and nothing at all of Daniel, and she didn’t comment on it.

“Coffee?”

“I’m fine.”

“It’s back here.”

He led her down the hall. He passed the closed door and his hand went flat against it and came away. She noticed that. He saw her notice it. Then he opened it.

He turned on the overhead light, and the room came up around them.

It had been Evan’s room. It had been Evan’s room for eighteen years and then, for thirty more, it had been this. The bed was gone. The dresser was gone. In their place was a long folding table from the Methodist church sale, covered in banker’s boxes, and above the table, on every wall, from the baseboard to the ceiling, were faces.

Missing-person flyers. Hundreds of them. Some Xeroxed so many times the faces were nearly gone, some typed on a manual typewriter with the e’s dropping below the line. Newspaper clippings, yellow and brittle and pinned through the corners. Topographic maps with pencil lines on them. Photographs of road cuts, logging roads, a fallen-in barn, a creek. A county map from 1951 with dozens of small red dots. Index cards in Daniel’s hand. Index cards in other hands.

And in the middle of the east wall, where the window used to be before he’d boarded it over, a single flyer, larger than the rest, laminated against the years.

MISSING. EVAN THOMAS RUSK. AGE 18. LAST SEEN SEPTEMBER 21, 1996, BLACKWATER COUNTY, N.C.

A boy in a senior picture. Long hair he’d been told to cut and hadn’t. A grin like he knew something the photographer didn’t.

Lena stood in the doorway a long time.

She walked in slow. She worked the walls like she’d worked the house, left to right, top to bottom. She read some of the flyers. She looked at the dates on the clippings. She touched the corner of the 1951 map and took her hand away.

When she got to Evan, she stopped.

“Your brother,” she said.

“Yes.”

“I’m sorry.”

“Thank you.”

She looked at the boy’s face a while longer. When she turned around her expression had settled into something careful, and kind, and Daniel had seen it before. He had seen it on Carrie, and on the pastor, and on the grief counselor the county had paid for in 2009 for six sessions, and on his own mother. It was the face people make at a man who has spent too long in a room.

“How long have you been doing this?” she asked. Gently.

“Since I was twenty.”

“That’s a long time.”

“It is.”

“Sheriff.” She hesitated. “Daniel. I know what it’s like to… I mean, I understand wanting there to be a pattern. When somebody’s gone, and there’s no answer, you start…” She gestured at the walls, and the gesture took in all of it, the maps and the thirty years. “You start seeing connections. Anybody would.”

“Sure.”

“I’m not saying it’s wrong.”

“You’re saying it’s sad.”

She didn’t answer that.

“The 1978 file’s in the third box,” Daniel said. “Della Pritchard. Nineteen. Disappeared January 1978 from the same property. Never found. There’s a copy of the original report and the deputy’s notes and some things I picked up later. You’re welcome to it.”

She went to the table. She found the third box. She lifted the lid and took out a file folder, thick, rubber-banded, and turned to go.

“There’s one more,” Daniel said.

He opened the drawer under the table. He had known since the morning he heard her name that he was going to open it, and he had not known until right now how he was going to do it. He took out a single sheet. It was a flyer, the inkjet kind from the early two-thousands, the colors already shifting toward green. He found an empty spot on the wall beside Evan, and he pushed in a pin at the top left corner and another at the top right, and he smoothed it flat.

MISSING. FRANK ALLEN MERCER. AGE 51. N.C. STATE BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION. LAST SEEN OCTOBER 9, 2001, BLACKWATER COUNTY, N.C.

A man in a coat and tie, a state ID photo, with dark hair going gray at the sides and his daughter’s square jaw.

Lena didn’t move.

“I was twenty-five,” Daniel said. “I was a deputy. I worked your daddy’s case for two years. I worked it till they told me to quit, and then I worked it some more.” He looked at the flyer, not at her. “Your mama brought you to the sheriff’s office one time. You sat in the waiting room with a coloring book while she talked to the sheriff. You colored the sky green. I asked you why and you said because it was your crayon.”

The file folder in Lena’s hands was bending.

“I know who you are, Agent Mercer,” Daniel said. “I knew who you were the minute you said your name.”

She put the folder down on the table. She did it carefully, squaring it with the edge. She took her car keys out of her pocket and looked at them like she couldn’t remember what they were for.

Then she walked out. Down the hall. Through the kitchen. He heard the Charger start, and heard it back down the drive too fast, and heard the gravel spit at the bottom where the drive met the road.

The 1978 file sat on the table where she had left it.8He couldn’t sleep, so he didn’t try.

At one in the morning he was parked on the shoulder of Creek Road with his lights off, a quarter mile past the Pritchard turnoff, at the one place where the road ran high enough that you could look down across the hayfield to the creek. He had a thermos of the coffee he hadn’t wanted and a pair of binoculars that had been his daddy’s and smelled like his daddy’s hunting coat, and he had told himself he was watching for Travis Cobb’s truck.

There was a moon, half of one, coming up over Frog Mountain. It laid a pale wash across the field and lit the creek in pieces where it ran over the shoals.

At ten past one, the back porch light came on.

Renee Cobb stepped out in a nightgown and a man’s flannel shirt. She had a saucer in her hand. She walked to the porch rail, the side that faced the creek, and she set the saucer on the flat top of the rail and looked down at it a moment. Then she went back inside and the light went off.

Daniel put the binoculars on the rail.

A biscuit. One biscuit, on a saucer, on the rail, facing the water.

He looked at it a long time.

A light came on upstairs. A small window under the eave, the room he’d have guessed was the boy’s. A lamp with a shade on it, yellow. Owen stood at the window in his Spider-Man shirt, his hands flat on the glass, looking out.

Not at the road. Down across the field, at the creek.

Daniel swung the binoculars.

At the tree line on the far bank, at the edge of the rhododendron where the shade had been so deep at three in the afternoon, two figures stood in the moonlight.

A woman in a pale dress, her hair up off her neck.

And beside her, a girl. A teenager in jeans and a T-shirt, barefoot, with her weight on one hip like a girl who’s been told to wait and doesn’t care for it.

Daniel’s hand found the door handle and stopped there.

Up in the window, Owen lifted one hand off the glass and waved.

Across the water, the girl waved back.

Sevdiğiniz yerleri alkışlamak için bir paragrafa dokunun.

Ne düşündünüz?

Alkışlamak için giriş yap

Bu bölümü nasıl buldunuz?

Giriş yap bir inceleme de yazmak için.

Yorumlar

Henüz yorum yok. İlk yorumu sen yap.