Lewati ke konten

Bab 1: Part One: Your BrotherBagian Pertama: Saudaramu

Bab ini belum tersedia dalam Indonesian. Masuk untuk menerjemahkannya dan bebaskan untuk semua orang.

1Walter Hale crossed the storage room in four steps and left water on every one of them.

Daniel didn’t get up. He sat in the folding chair in the dark with his hands on his knees and watched the old man come, and the gray light from the hall came in behind Walter and showed the water running off the hem of his canvas coat and pooling on the linoleum, and the rain sound that had come in the side door with him went on in the hall, hard and steady, though through the open door at the end of the hall Daniel could see the parking lot dry in the sun.

Walter stopped at the folding table. He looked down at Evan’s flyer. He looked at it a long time, like a man checking a face he’d carried in his head against the original.

Then he put his hand in the pocket of the canvas coat and took it out closed, and set something down on the table beside the flyer, beside the boy’s laminated face, and took his hand away.

A ring.

Daniel didn’t need the light. He knew it by the shape. He reached up anyway and pulled the chain on the bare bulb over the table, and the bulb swung and the light swung with it, back and forth across the table, across Evan’s face and the ring.

Gold, or what passes for gold on a class ring. A blue stone, square cut. Around the stone, raised letters: BLACKWATER HIGH SCHOOL. A panther on one side, crouched. On the other side, the year.

Daniel picked it up. It was cold. He turned it to the swinging light and looked inside the band and the letters were there in the small machine script, the same as he’d seen them on the counter at Haskett’s Jewelry in March of 1995, when Evan had laid down three hundred and twelve dollars in ones and fives he’d saved from a year at Hardee’s and the jeweler had counted it twice. Or it was the jewelry counter at the Belk in Sylva. He’d been sure of Haskett’s for thirty years and now, holding it, he wasn’t, and it mattered more than it should, and he couldn’t make it stop mattering.

E.R.

He’d been wearing it that night. At the fire. Daniel had seen it on his hand when Evan held out the flashlight and said come on, Danny. The blue stone catching the firelight.

The bulb slowed its swing and stopped.

“He said you’d know it,” Walter said.2Walter sat down on a banker’s box marked 1984–1986 and put his hands on his knees. He sat like a man on a church pew in a strange church, upright, not leaning on anything. The water was still running off his coat. It ran down the side of the box and darkened the cardboard, and Daniel thought, before he could stop himself, that 1984 to 1986 was the Shook barn fire and the Teague boy that drowned at the quarry, and that Bev had a way she wanted those labeled and the water would take the label off. His laces didn’t match. Walter’s. One brown, one black, both soaked. Daniel looked at them a long time for no reason he could have given anybody.

Daniel held the ring in his fist.

“Where,” he said. It came out wrong. He tried again. “Where did you get this.”

“Your brother give it to me.”

“When?”

Walter looked at the wall. There was nothing on it. Daniel hadn’t put anything back up. Just cinderblock painted the green of every county building in North Carolina, and a water stain shaped like Ohio.

“I’d been lost two days,” Walter said. “Over there. That’s how it felt. Two days. I’d run off from where my daddy was and I couldn’t find the road back. Everything kept changing. I’d lay down to sleep under a laurel and wake up and the leaves would be off it. I’d find a creek and follow it and it’d go uphill.” He said it plainly, like a man describing a bad stretch of road. “Second night I sat down by a creek in the dark and I quit. I was seventeen years old and I sat down and cried for my mama.”

Daniel waited.

“And somebody said my name.”

“Who?”

“A boy. A young man. I thought at first it was one of the Voss boys, he talked like home. He come up out of the dark with a flashlight. Long hair to here.” Walter touched his own jaw. “Jean jacket, too big for him. He squatted down by me at the creek and shined the light on my face, and he said, You’re Walter Hale. Not asking. Telling. Like he’d been looking for me.”

“What did he look like?”

Walter turned his head and looked at the flyer on the table. At the senior picture under the laminate. The long hair. The grin.

He didn’t answer. He didn’t have to.

“He walked me out,” Walter said. “All night. He knew where he was going. He kept his hand on my back. He said don’t look at anything, just look at my feet, and I did. We walked till it got gray, and then there was the tree line, and the landing, and Buck Voss’s loader. And he stopped me right at the edge.” Walter’s big hands moved on his knees. “He took that ring off his finger and put it in my hand and closed my fingers on it. And he said, Give this to my brother. He’ll know it.”

The ring was hot now in Daniel’s fist. He didn’t know how long he’d been squeezing it.

“That was 1976,” Daniel said.

“That’s when I come out.”

“Evan was born in 1978.”

“I know when he was born.”

“He went missing in September of 1996. He was eighteen years old. He was standing at a fire with me on the Voss lease wearing this ring on his right hand twenty years after you say he gave it to you.”

“I know it.”

“Then how?”

Walter looked at him. His face was sixty-seven years old or eighty-four, depending on which part of it you looked at. The eyes were seventeen.

“I don’t know what year it is over there, Sheriff,” he said. “I don’t believe anybody does.”

Daniel opened his hand and looked at the ring in his palm. There was a red mark across the skin where the edge of the stone had cut in.

“Fifty years,” he said. “You’ve had it fifty years.”

“In Daddy’s tackle box.”

“Why didn’t you…” He stopped. “In 1996. When the flyers went up. When his face was on every pole in this county. Why didn’t you bring it to me then?”

“Because you was twenty,” Walter said. “And you’d have gone up after him that night.”

Daniel didn’t say anything.

“I watched you,” Walter said. “Those first years. Everybody did. You’d drive the logging roads at night with a spotlight. You’d walk the Bell lease on your days off. Your mama called the sheriff on you once, she was so scared. If I’d give you that ring in 1996 you’d have been up that mountain before I got off your porch.” He looked at the floor, at the water around his boots. “And he asked me not to let you.”

“He what?”

“He said two things. At the tree line. Give this to my brother. And don’t let him come.” Walter’s voice didn’t change. “He made me promise. Stood there with his hand on my arm till I said it.”

The rain went on in the hall. Daniel looked through the doorway at the dry sun on the parking lot.

“Why now?” he asked.

“Because y’all dug up the Mercer man.” Walter looked at him. “Because there’s a county road truck sitting at the washout on the Bell lease that ain’t been seen since I was a boy. Because the storm last night was the same storm. It’s started again, Sheriff. Whatever it is. And you’re a grown man now with a badge and a key to every gate in this county, and you’re going to go up there whether I give you this or not.”

“Then why give it to me?”

“Because he asked me to.” Walter stood. His knees cracked. “And because I’m going to ask you for something for it.”

Daniel waited.

“I’ll tell you what happened in 1959,” Walter said. “All of it. What I saw over there and who I saw and what they done. I’ve never told a living soul. Not Annie. Not her mama, God rest her. I’ll tell you.” He looked down at Daniel in the folding chair. “But first you’re going to swear to me you won’t go up that road. Not ever. Not for your brother. Not for the Mercer girl’s daddy. Not for nobody.”

“Walter.”

“I promised him. Fifty years ago. It’s the only thing anybody over there ever asked of me.” He held out his hand. It was steady. “I can’t keep it by myself anymore.”

Daniel looked at the hand. Big and square, grease in the creases, a mechanic’s hand. Then he looked at the ring in his own palm, and at the boy on the flyer, and at the water still running down the side of the banker’s box marked 1984–1986.

He stood up.

He put the ring in his shirt pocket and buttoned the flap over it. Then he took Walter Hale’s hand. It was cold and it smelled like WD-40 and something else, sweet, he couldn’t place it. Orange peel. Or it was the room.

“I swear,” Daniel said.

Walter held on a moment longer than a handshake. Then he let go and turned and walked out of the storage room and down the hall, and Daniel stood in the doorway and watched him go, and saw what he hadn’t seen while Walter was sitting.

The old man’s coat was dry. His hair was dry. In the hall behind him there was no sound of rain at all.

Daniel turned around to look at the floor by the table, where the puddle had been, and the light from the bulb was in his eyes, and he put his hand up against it, and by the time he’d moved out from under it he’d forgotten to look. Later he would try to remember whether the box marked 1984–1986 had been wet when he came back to it. He thought it had a stain on it. He thought it might always have had a stain on it.3Lena slept three hours at the Mountain View Motel and woke up at ten to the sound of somebody pounding on her door.

She lay there. Her hands hurt. She held them up in front of her face and looked at them in the light from the curtains, and they were the hands of somebody who’d dug a grave in the rain, broken blisters packed with red clay she’d been too tired to wash out, and for a second she didn’t know where she was or why.

Then she did.

The ice machine outside her window was making the sound it made on even-numbered days, a long gargle and then a crack, and she lay there hating it with a completeness that surprised her. It was the only thing in the county she was sure she hated. She held onto that for a minute.

The pounding came again.

She opened the door in yesterday’s jeans and a T-shirt. Daniel was standing on the walk. He’d shaved. He had on a clean uniform shirt. He looked like a man who hadn’t slept at all and had decided not to mention it.

“Get dressed,” he said.

“I don’t work for anybody.”

“I know it. Get dressed anyway.”

“Why?”

“There’s a girl missing on the Bell lease,” Daniel said. “And I’d like you to come help me find her.”


Her name was Priya Raman. She was twenty-six and a doctoral student in geology at Appalachian State in Boone, and for the last month she had been living in a rented camper at the Laurel Fork campground and spending her days on the upper Bell lease, taking core samples for the state’s reservoir feasibility study. Her advisor had called the sheriff’s office at nine. Priya had texted him at four the afternoon before that the storm had exposed some interesting sediment on a slide below Laurel Knob, and that she was going up to log it while the light lasted, and he hadn’t heard from her since.

Her truck was at the end of the Bell Road, at the gate to the upper lease. A white state pickup with the Division of Water Resources seal on the door. Locked. A core sampling kit in the bed. A water bottle on the dash, half full.

Lena stood beside it with her hands in her jacket pockets so nobody would see them.

“Search and rescue’s coming from Swain,” Daniel said. “Two hours. Cody’s bringing the dogs.”

“What do you need me for?”

He looked at her.

“You found the last one,” he said.

Her phone buzzed. A radio, actually, a county handheld he’d given her in the truck without comment, clipped to the pocket of her jacket. She’d forgotten it was there. It crackled.

“Sheriff, Hargrove.” Coy’s voice. “Bev says you’ve got the Mercer woman with you up at the Bell gate.”

Daniel unclipped his own radio. “That’s right.”

“She’s not law enforcement anymore. She resigned. It was on the scanner traffic out of Raleigh this morning.”

“I’m aware.”

“Then I’d like to know in what capacity she’s on scene, sir.”

Daniel looked at Lena. Lena looked at the radio on her own pocket, and then at him.

“Civilian volunteer,” Daniel said into the radio. “Search and rescue. Same as Cody Voss and his cousins. You want to come up here and run her off, Coy, you’re welcome to the drive.”

The radio hissed for a while.

“Copy,” Coy said.

Daniel clipped his radio back on his shoulder. He didn’t look at her. He walked over to the gate and started checking the lock on it, which didn’t need checking, and Lena stood by the state truck and found that she was not going to cry about a radio call, and then found that she needed a minute to be sure of it.4Cody’s dogs took them up the Bell lease, just as Daniel had known they would.

Up the old logging road past the washout, where the county truck still sat in the ditch rusted to lace with the sun going straight through the holes in its roof. Daniel didn’t look at it. Lena did. She stopped and stood by it for a while and looked at the door, BLACKWATER CO. ROADS, No. 4, and then she walked on without asking him anything. He was grateful.

Past the washout the dogs left the road and went up through the timber on a game trail, and then along the side of the mountain under Laurel Knob, and Daniel knew before they came out of the poplars where they were going to come out.

The Voss landing above Hale Gap. The rust-red frame of the old shed. The saplings coming up through the gravel.

And on the far side of the landing, the woods. The wall of hemlock and rhododendron so thick it looked solid, and the old skid road going into it like a mouth.

The dogs went across the landing at a dead run and stopped at the edge of the trees.

Dolly sat down. Hank stood beside her with his hackles up and his tail tucked hard between his legs, and he made a sound Daniel had never heard a dog make, low, more like a word than a whine.

Cody came across the gravel and stood behind them. He didn’t tell them to go on. He just stood there.

“She went in,” he said.

Daniel walked over and stood beside him at the line where the gravel ended and the leaf litter began. Where Walter Hale had stood in his boots most nights for fifty years.

He looked in under the hemlocks. Dark, even at noon. Green and black and still. Somewhere back in there, he could hear water. A creek. Running.

“Sheriff,” Cody said. Low.

“I know.”

“I ain’t going in there.”

“I know you’re not.”

Lena came up on his other side. She was breathing hard from the climb. She looked into the trees, and he watched her listen, and watched her hear the water, and watched her decide not to say so.

“Then we go in,” she said.

He felt the ring in his shirt pocket. The edge of it through the cloth, against his chest, where his heart was. He’d felt it all morning. He felt it now like a hand.

Not for your brother. Not for the Mercer girl’s daddy. Not for nobody.

“No,” Daniel said.

Lena turned and looked at him.

“We wait for search and rescue,” he said. “We grid the landing and the slope below it. We put a team on the old road from the Hale Gap side.”

“She’s in there.”

“Maybe.”

“The dogs say she’s in there. Daniel. She’s been in there since four o’clock yesterday. There’s a creek. There was a storm.”

“I know it.”

“Then what are we…”

“I gave my word,” he said.

She stopped.

He didn’t look at her. He looked into the trees. He could feel her looking at him, at the side of his face, and he could feel her working it out, because she was good at working things out, and he could feel the moment she decided she didn’t have enough to work it out with and wasn’t going to get it from him standing at the edge of the Voss landing with Cody Voss three feet away.

“Your word to who?” she asked.

He didn’t answer.

The search and rescue team from Swain got there at one-thirty, eight of them in orange, with ropes and radios and a drone. They gridded the landing. They gridded the slope below it. They flew the drone up over the hemlocks and back and down the hollow, and the screen showed nothing but green, and two of them went in a hundred yards on the old skid road and came out again and said it petered out in laurel hell and there was no way through.

Daniel sat on the tailgate of Cody’s truck and waited.

Lena didn’t sit. She walked the edge of the trees. Back and forth, along the line, slowly, all afternoon, like a dog walking a fence it can’t get over. Once she stopped and put her hand on the trunk of a hemlock at the edge and stood like that a while, and then took it away.

He watched her and then he didn’t. He thought about whether Lynn had remembered to let the dog out, and decided she had, and then wasn’t sure, and got out his phone to text her and didn’t have a signal and put it back. A jay was going at something in the poplars below the landing, the same two notes, over and over, for most of an hour. The search team’s drone made a sound like a box fan. Somebody on the team had a bag of the sour cream and onion chips and the smell of them came across the gravel every time the wind turned, and he could not stop smelling it, and he was not hungry. The sun moved across the landing and the shadows of the saplings moved with it, slow, so slow you couldn’t see it happen, only that it had. Lena walked. She went down the line to the rust-red shed frame and turned and came back to the big hemlock and turned. Eleven times. He counted, and then lost count, and then started over from one, which made no sense, and he knew it made no sense. Around four a yellow leaf came off a poplar and took a long time to come down, turning, and he watched it the whole way, and it landed on the gravel a foot from the tree line and lay there, and nothing happened to it. He didn’t know what he’d thought would happen to it.

At 6:40, with the light going gold, the dogs stood up.

They both stood at once. Dolly first, then Hank. Their heads came up and their ears came forward and they looked into the trees, and Cody, who’d been dozing in the cab of his truck, sat up and said, “Hey.”

A girl walked out of the woods.

She came out of the dark under the hemlocks onto the gravel of the landing like somebody stepping out of a store onto a sidewalk. She had a backpack on and a rock hammer in one hand, and she was dark-haired and small and very annoyed, and she stopped when she saw them all, the eight people in orange and the sheriff and Lena and Cody and the dogs and the drone, and she said, “Oh, my God. What happened?”5Priya Raman was fine. That was the first thing and the thing Lena would write down at the top of the page.

She was hungry and her phone was dead, and she was mortified, and once she understood what the eight people in orange were there for she was furious, at herself first and then at her advisor for calling the sheriff. She sat on the tailgate of Cody’s truck with a bottle of water from the search team and a space blanket she didn’t need over her shoulders, and she kept saying it had been an hour. Two at the most.

“It’s six-forty-five,” Lena said.

“In the evening?”

“Today. Wednesday.”

Priya looked at her. She looked at the sky over Laurel Knob, going orange. She looked at her dead phone in her hand.

“I went in at four-thirty,” she said. “Yesterday? I went in at four-thirty yesterday. I followed the slide up. There’s this incredible exposure, the storm stripped about two meters of overburden off a slope above the creek and there’s old fill in it, and I wanted to log it before…” She stopped. “Twenty-six hours?”

“Tell me what happened,” Lena said. “From the slide.”

Priya told her.

She’d followed the slide up to where it had torn loose. Above it, in the woods, she’d found a road. An old one, a cut along the side of the hollow with stone cribbing along the downhill side, dry-laid, beautiful work, the stones fitted without mortar. She’d been excited. You didn’t see cribbing like that on logging roads; it was older than logging, wagon road work, maybe nineteenth century. She’d started photographing it and logging it and following it up the hollow.

“And then there was a woman,” Priya said.

Lena kept her pen moving.

“Older. Fifties, maybe? Or forties. Hard to tell. Dark hair going gray, up in a bun. She had on this huge man’s raincoat that came down to her shins, and galoshes. Black rubber galoshes, with the buckles.” Priya almost laughed. “Like my grandmother had in Ohio. And she had a notebook. A composition book, the black and white kind. She was writing in it when I came around the bend.”

“What did she say?”

“She asked me what I was doing on her road.” Priya pulled the space blanket tighter. “I said it was Bell timber land and I had a permit. And she looked at me like I was a child who’d said something adorable. And she said, This road doesn’t belong to the Bells, honey. It never did.”

“Then what?”

“Then she asked me my name.” Priya picked at the label of the water bottle. “And I told her.”

Lena’s pen stopped.

“Your whole name?” Daniel asked. He’d come up beside the truck. Lena hadn’t heard him.

Priya looked up at him. “Yes? Priya Raman. Why?”

He didn’t answer.

“She wrote it in her notebook,” Priya said. “Wrong, actually. I watched her. She spelled it P-R-E-A, like everybody does, and I almost said something and then I didn’t, because, I don’t know. You don’t correct a person like that.” She frowned. “Is that weird? That I didn’t? I correct everybody. My advisor’s been calling me Pree-ya for three years and I correct him every time.” She lost the thread and found it. “Anyway. And then she said, You don’t belong to anybody here, so you can go on home. Turn around and go back the way you came, and don’t you come back up this road. And she said it so…” Priya stopped. “Like a teacher. Like when you’re in third grade and the teacher says it and you just do it. You don’t even think about it. So I turned around and walked back down the road and down the slide and through the trees, and I came out here.” She looked around the landing at all of them. “And it was an hour. I swear it was an hour.”

Lena wrote it down. Subj. reports female, 40s–50s, gray-dark hair in bun, man’s raincoat, galoshes, comp. notebook. Asked subj.’s full name. Recorded it. Instructed subj. to leave and not return. She looked at what she’d written. She did not put anything in the margin.

Daniel had turned away. He was standing at the edge of the landing with his back to them, looking into the trees.

“Daniel,” Lena said.

He didn’t turn around.

“Who wears galoshes?” she asked.

He was quiet a long time. The search team was packing up the drone. Cody was loading the dogs. Down in the hollow a whip-poor-will started.

“A schoolteacher,” Daniel said. “In 1959.”


They drove Priya down to her truck in the dark with Cody’s taillights ahead of them on the logging road. She fell asleep in the back seat of the Tahoe before they reached the washout, curled against the door with the space blanket crackling every time she breathed.

Lena didn’t say anything until they passed the county truck. The headlights swept across it, the rust and the holes and the white letters on the door, and moved on, and it was dark again.

“Your word to who?” she asked.

He kept his eyes on the road.

“Somebody who asked me for one thing,” he said. “One thing, in fifty years.”

“Walter Hale.”

He didn’t answer. In the back seat Priya shifted in her sleep and the blanket crackled.

“He came to you,” Lena said. “This morning. After the grave. That’s why you looked like that at my door.”

“Like what?”

“Like you’d been given something you didn’t want.”

The Tahoe bounced through a rut. Daniel’s hand came off the wheel and went to his shirt pocket and touched the flap of it, and went back to the wheel.

“I’ll tell you,” he said. “When I can. I’m asking you for some time.”

She looked at his hand on the wheel. Then out her window at the dark going by, the trees, and somewhere below them in the hollow the sound of water she couldn’t place.

“All right,” she said.6The call from the medical examiner came nineteen days later, on a Monday.

Lena was in Daniel’s office, at his desk, in his chair, because he’d told her to use it while he was at a meeting with the county commissioners about the storm damage. She’d been going through the Mercer case file from 2001 for the third time, the official one, the SBI file Hal Brookshire had closed in 2003. She knew it by heart. She read it anyway.

Bev put the call through.

“Ms. Mercer? This is Dr. Okonkwo at the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner in Raleigh. I have results on the remains recovered in Blackwater County. You’re listed as next of kin, and the county coroner asked that we contact you directly.”

The county coroner. Lena looked at the door of the office, where Daniel’s hat hung on a hook.

“Yes.”

“Would you like me to go over them by phone, or would you prefer to receive the written report?”

“Both,” Lena said. “Please.”

Dr. Okonkwo went over them. Lena wrote it down, every word, on a yellow legal pad from Daniel’s drawer. Her hand was steady. She watched it be steady.

The DNA comparison with the reference sample provided by Ms. Mercer, a buccal swab, showed a parent-child relationship with a probability exceeding 99.99 percent. The remains were those of Frank Allen Mercer.

The skeletal remains were consistent with a white male between sixty and seventy years of age at death. Degenerative changes of the spine and major joints were advanced. Cranial sutures were fully fused.

There were multiple lytic lesions in the lumbar vertebrae, the pelvis, and the left femur, consistent with metastatic disease. Most likely a primary cancer of the prostate or lung. Cause of death could not be determined with confidence from skeletal remains alone, but the metastatic disease would have been advanced and very likely fatal.

The dental work included a three-unit fixed bridge, lower right, of a porcelain-fused-to-metal type, with a casting alloy and cement that had been largely superseded in general practice by the early 1990s.

“Dr. Okonkwo,” Lena said. “My father disappeared in 2001 at the age of fifty-one. He had no cancer diagnosis. He had all his teeth. I have his dental records.”

“I understand,” Dr. Okonkwo said. She had a careful, kind voice. Lena had heard it before, on other calls, telling other people things. “Ms. Mercer, I’ve been doing this twenty-two years. I’m telling you what the bones tell me. The DNA is your father. The bones are a man in his sixties who’d been dying of cancer for some time and had dental work done in, I’d estimate, the mid to late nineteen-eighties.” A pause. “I’ve written it up exactly that way. I’ve also noted that it’s inconsistent with the case history. I’ll be honest with you. I don’t have an explanation, and I’m not going to put one in the report I don’t have.”

“Thank you,” Lena said.

“I’m very sorry for your loss.”

“Thank you.”

She hung up.

The written report came through on Daniel’s fax machine fifteen minutes later, eleven pages, the old thermal paper curling. Lena tore it off and laid it flat on the desk and weighted the corners with Daniel’s stapler and coffee mug and a rock that said BLACKWATER COUNTY FAIR 2019 and the desk phone, and she read it.

She read it twice, start to finish, with her finger moving down the left margin. Every line. Every number.

She held the pen over the margin the whole second time through. She did not write anything in it.

Then she picked up Daniel’s desk phone and dialed her mother.

Joanne answered on the second ring with the bright voice she used for numbers she didn’t recognize. “This is Joanne.”

“Mom. It’s me.”

“Lena.” The brightness went out. “Where are you calling from? This isn’t your cell.”

“The sheriff’s office in Blackwater.”

A silence. Lena could hear the kitchen behind her mother. The radio on the windowsill, the one that only got the classical station out of Charlotte. Water running and then shut off.

“You said you’d be home by now,” Joanne said. “You said two weeks. Dennis said Dana called him. Dana said you…”

“Mom. They found Dad.”

The silence went on so long that Lena took the receiver away from her ear and looked at it to see if the call had dropped.

“Found him,” her mother said.

“His remains. Here. In a family cemetery on a farm. The state medical examiner confirmed it this morning with my DNA.” Lena looked at the report under the stapler and the coffee mug. “It’s him.”

She heard her mother sit down. The scrape of a kitchen stool on tile.

“How long,” Joanne said. “How long has he been… When did he die? Did he die that week? Was it right away? Lena, did he…” Her voice went up. “Did he suffer?”

Lena looked at the report. Sixty to seventy years of age. Metastatic disease. Dental work consistent with the mid to late nineteen-eighties.

She opened her mouth to answer and found that there was no answer that her mother could hold.

“They don’t know yet,” Lena said. “They’re still working on it.”

“But it’s him.”

“It’s him.”

Her mother made a sound. Lena had heard it once before, when she was nine, the morning they found the beagle under the porch. Then the stool scraped again on the tile and the radio in the background got louder, like her mother had leaned over and turned it up, which made no sense, and Lena sat in Daniel’s chair and listened to somebody’s violin concerto out of Charlotte for what felt like a long time.

“Bring him home,” Joanne said. “Lena. Bring him home. There’s a plot at Oakwood next to Granddaddy. I bought it in 2003. I never told you. I never told Dennis. Bring him home and put him there.”

Lena held the receiver. Through Daniel’s window she could see the courthouse square, and the Confederate soldier on his pedestal, and beyond the rooftops the long blue line of Frog Mountain with the first color starting in the trees.

“I don’t know where home was, Mom,” she said.

“What does that mean?”

“I don’t know.” She closed her eyes. “I’ll call you tonight. I love you.”

She hung up before her mother could ask her anything else, and sat with her hand on the receiver, and didn’t take it off for a long time.


When Daniel came back from the commissioners at four, she was still sitting there. He stood in the door and looked at her, and at the report, and didn’t come in.

“It’s him,” she said.

“I know. She called me too. After you.”

“Sixty to seventy. Cancer in his bones. A bridge from the eighties.” She looked at the report. “He had all his teeth, Daniel. When he left. I remember his teeth. He used to make his jaw pop at breakfast to make me laugh.”

Daniel came in and sat down in the chair across the desk. The visitor’s chair. His own office, and he sat in the visitor’s chair, and she noticed it, and he saw her notice.

He put a banker’s box on the desk between them.

It was soft and brown and warped, with water lines on the sides like the rings in a tree. The label on the end was in old faded marker, and it said 14.

“Judge’s clerk dropped it off at noon,” he said. “Box 14. Sheriff’s Department case files, 1955 to 1965.”

She lifted the lid.

Inside, filling the bottom of the box, was a single block of paper. Hundreds of pages fused together into one slab, swollen and dried and swollen again, gray and brown, the edges furred. It smelled like a basement. Here and there on the side of the block you could see the edge of a folder tab, a typed word, a date.

She put her hand on it. It was hard as wood.

“The 1959 file’s in there,” Daniel said. “Somewhere. Doris says the ’77 flood got it. Says the judge’s granddaddy had it moved upstairs to dry, and it dried like that.”

“And box 31?”

“Not located at this time.”

She took her hand off the block of paper and looked at him.

“I signed for 14 as coroner,” Daniel said. “And I told the judge’s clerk I’d be back for 31 the same way.” He looked at the box. “I expect it’ll stay not located a while.”

Lena put the lid back on box 14.

“Daniel,” she said. “How did my father get to be sixty-six years old?”

He didn’t answer. He sat across from her in his own visitor’s chair, and he put his hand flat on his shirt pocket, over something small that she couldn’t see, and he held it there.7The Blackwater County Board of Commissioners met on the first and third Tuesdays of the month in a room on the second floor of the courthouse with a drop ceiling and a flag in the corner and five chairs behind a long table on a riser, so the commissioners sat eight inches higher than everybody else. Daniel had always figured that was the point of the riser.

He stood at the podium in his uniform with a single sheet of paper.

“I’m asking for one position,” he said. “Detective. Investigations. This county hasn’t had a dedicated investigator since 2011. My deputies are good. They’re patrol. We’ve had a missing juvenile, a hostage situation, felony forgery, a cattle killing, and an unregistered burial in the last two months, and every one of them got worked by me and a state agent on loan. The state agent’s gone. I need somebody.”

The chairman was Royce Bell Ammons, who was a Bell on his mother’s side. Next to him was Faye Hargrove Pruitt, the judge’s sister. Next to her was a Hargrove by marriage. The other two were a retired Shook who ran the feed store and a Baptist preacher’s widow named Coralee Hensley who brought her knitting to every meeting and was the only one Daniel had ever seen vote against the other four.

“The budget’s set, Sheriff,” Royce Ammons said. “It was set in June.”

“I know it was.”

“And I understand the person you have in mind for this position is Frank Mercer’s daughter.” Royce looked at his paper, though there was nothing about it on his paper. “Who resigned from the SBI last month under a cloud. Who dug up a grave on Raines land in violation of a court order.”

“She assisted the county coroner in recovering remains.”

“That’s one way of putting it.”

“It’s the way it’s going to be put in the report.”

Faye Hargrove Pruitt leaned forward. “Move to table,” she said.

“Second,” said the Hargrove by marriage.

They voted. Four to one. Coralee Hensley looked up from her knitting long enough to say “Nay,” and looked back down.

“Tabled,” Royce Ammons said. “Next item. Culvert replacement on Upper Laurel Road.”

Daniel picked up his sheet of paper and folded it in half and put it in his shirt pocket, next to the ring. He walked out of the meeting room and down the stairs and across the courthouse square to the annex.


The drug forfeiture account was a line in the sheriff’s budget that the commissioners didn’t vote on, because by state law they couldn’t. It was money taken in seizures, mostly from meth cooks and pill mills, and by law it could only be spent on law enforcement purposes, and by law the sheriff decided what those purposes were. It had sixty-one thousand dollars in it. Daniel had been saving it for a new radio system.

He went into Bev’s office and told her.

Bev looked at him over her reading glasses for a long time.

“The commissioners just tabled it,” she said.

“They tabled a budget line. I’m not asking for a budget line.”

“Royce Ammons is going to have a stroke.”

“I hope not. He’s a deacon at my cousin’s church.”

Bev took off her glasses and let them drop on the chain around her neck. She’d been the dispatcher in Blackwater County since 1989. She had dispatched Daniel’s daddy to the last call of his career and Daniel to his first.

“You’re sure about this,” she said. “About her.”

“I’m sure.”

“Because I’ve seen how you look at her, Danny. Everybody has. Carrie has. My sister’s boy has, and he’s got the macular degeneration.”

“That’s not what this is.”

“I didn’t say it was.” Bev stood up. “I said I’ve seen it. Go get her. I’ll find the Bible.”


Lena came at six, from the room she’d rented above the florist on Depot Street. She’d moved out of the motel that morning with everything she owned in Blackwater in two duffel bags and her father’s box. She came into the annex in jeans and a gray sweater with her hair down, which he’d never seen, and stopped in Bev’s doorway and looked at the two of them, and at the Bible on Bev’s desk, and at the small black case beside it.

“What is this?” she said.

“Detective’s position,” Daniel said. “Investigations. It pays forty-one thousand a year, which is less than half what you made in Raleigh. You’d work for me. You’d answer to me. You’d carry a county star, which the state will tell you doesn’t mean anything, and the people of this county will tell you means everything. The commissioners tabled it at five-fifteen. I’m funding it out of drug money until they make me stop.”

Lena didn’t move.

“You’d get the case,” he said. “All of it. Your father’s. Evan’s. 1959. Whatever comes next. You’d have a badge to work it with, and nobody in Raleigh could take it off you.”

She looked at the Bible on Bev’s desk. It was Bev’s own, white leather, cracked at the spine, with her name stamped on the cover in gold that had mostly worn off.

“Why?” she asked.

“Because you’re the best investigator I’ve ever seen,” Daniel said. “And because it’s going to take two of us.”

She looked at him a long time.

Then she walked to the desk and put her left hand on Bev’s Bible, and raised her right.

Bev read the oath. Daniel had heard it a hundred times and he listened to every word. Support and maintain the Constitution and laws of the United States, and the Constitution and laws of North Carolina. Faithfully discharge the duties of the office, so help me God. Lena said it back, every line, in a clear even voice. Her right hand was raised and the palm was healing, the blisters gone to pink new skin, and he looked at it while she spoke.

When it was done Bev opened the small black case.

A county star. Seven points, gold-toned, with the seal of North Carolina in the center and around it the words BLACKWATER COUNTY SHERIFF, and across the bottom, on a little ribbon of metal, DETECTIVE. Bev had ordered it from a company in Raleigh twenty days ago, the morning after Walter came in, without anybody asking her to.

Lena took it out of the case. She turned it over. She looked at the pin on the back. Then she clipped it on the waistband of her jeans, on the left side, where her SBI badge had been for nine years, and stood there with her hand over it.

“Well,” Bev said, and blew her nose. “Welcome to Blackwater County, honey.”8Adrian called at nine-thirty that night, while Lena was unpacking.

The room above Juanita Pruitt’s florist was one room with a kitchenette and a bathroom with a claw-foot tub somebody had painted pink. It smelled like carnations from downstairs, and like the old building, plaster and a hundred years of coal smoke in the walls. There was a bed and a card table with two folding chairs. Juanita had said the radiator knocked but worked. It was knocking now.

“Lee.” Adrian sounded tired. She could hear the TV behind him, low. “Meg says Dana says you’ve got a job.”

“I’ve got a job.”

“With the sheriff.”

“With the county.”

He was quiet a moment. She waited for it. The reasonable voice. Lee, think about this. Lee, you’re grieving. Lee, you’ve lost perspective. She’d had her answers ready since the commission meeting, lined up in order like evidence.

“Okay,” Adrian said.

She waited.

“Okay,” he said again. “If that’s what you need.”

“It’s through Christmas,” Lena said. “At least. There’s a lot to… There’s a case. A lot of it’s my father’s.”

“I know. I figured.” She heard him set something down. A glass. “Do what you need to do. I’ll be here.”

“Adrian.”

“I mean it. I’m not going to fight you on this, Lee. I know better.” He laughed a little. “I’ll come up some weekend. You can show me the famous Blackwater Grill.”

“Okay.”

“I love you.”

“I love you.”

She hung up and stood there in the middle of the room with the phone in her hand and the radiator knocking.

He’d taken it well. He’d said every right thing in the right order.

She went in the bathroom and ran the pink tub full, as hot as it would go, and sat on the edge of it with her shoes on and watched the steam come up, and didn’t get in. After a while she pulled the plug.


Daniel called Walter at ten from the porch of his cousin’s house on Laurel Fork Road, with the cousin’s dog asleep across his boots.

Annie answered. She was polite and short. She put her daddy on.

“Walter,” Daniel said. “I kept my word. Twenty days. I stood at the landing and didn’t go in. I’d like the rest of it.”

The line was quiet. He could hear a television, and Walter breathing.

“I know you would,” Walter said.

“You said you’d tell me what happened in 1959.”

“I said I would. I didn’t say how.” Another quiet. “I don’t know if I can say it to a face, Sheriff. I been thinking. Fifty years I never said it out loud. I don’t know if I can sit across from a man and say what I seen.”

“Then don’t say it to a face.”

“How else?”

Daniel looked out at the dark. At Laurel Fork Road going off into the trees. At the ridge beyond it, black against the stars, and somewhere back in there, a mile or two or a hundred years, the old road.

“However you can,” he said.

Walter was quiet a long time.

“I’ll think on it,” he said, and hung up.9Lena unpacked her father’s box onto the card table at midnight.

The thirty-one folders, in order, as she’d found them. The vellum map, folded. The shoebox with the index cards in the old hand and the new. The photograph from 1974 in its plastic sleeve. She laid them out as she had on the butcher paper in Daniel’s conference room, left to right, 1863 to 1996, and stood looking at them under the light from the bare bulb in the ceiling.

Juanita had left a paper sack on the card table, and in it, wrapped in wax paper, two sausage biscuits from the Grill, gone cold, with a note: welcome to the building. Lena ate one standing up, over the sink, and put the other in the little refrigerator, and forgot it there for a week.

Then she took the watch out of her jacket pocket.

She’d carried it there for twenty days. She’d slept with it on the nightstand at the motel. She’d held it in her pocket in Daniel’s office while she read the fax.

She sat down in one of the folding chairs and turned it over in her hands.

A Seiko. Steel. The expansion band was rusted brown and stiff, and there was red clay still packed in the links. The crystal was cracked straight across. Under it the face had gone the color of weak tea, and the hands were stopped at 4:17. She didn’t know which 4:17. Morning or afternoon. Which year.

On the back, under the clay, F.M. from J. 1993.

She got up and got a dish towel from the kitchenette, a clean one, white with a red stripe, that Juanita had left folded on the counter. She wet one corner of it at the sink and sat back down and cleaned the watch. Slowly. Link by link. She worked the clay out of the band with the corner of the towel and her thumbnail, and rinsed the corner, and did it again, until the towel was pink with it and the steel showed through, dull and pitted.

When it was as clean as it was going to get, she held it up to the light.

Then she opened the band and slid it over her left hand and let it close on her wrist.

It was big on her. It slid down to the bone. It was heavier than she’d expected, and cold, and then not cold.

She looked at the face. 4:17. The second hand stopped just past the six, where it had been stopped in the ground for however many years it had been in the ground, in whatever year it had gone in.

There was a crown on the side. She could wind it. It might even run.

She looked at it a long time.

She didn’t wind it.

Ketuk paragraf untuk menyorak bagian yang kamu suka.

Apa pendapatmu?

Masuk untuk menyorak

Bagaimana bab ini?

Masuk untuk menulis ulasan juga.

Ulasan

Belum ada ulasan. Jadilah yang pertama.