1The first thing was the cold.
Daniel came out of the hemlocks onto the gravel of the Voss landing and the cold hit him in the chest like a hand. Not April cold. Not rain cold. Dry and hard and deep. It got into his teeth. He stopped. He stood there at the line with his boots on the gravel and the dark of the trees at his back and breathed, and his breath went out of him white.
It was dawn. Gray light coming up behind Frog Mountain. The saplings on the landing were bare and every one of them was furred white with frost, every twig, so the whole landing looked like it had been dipped in sugar. The gravel crunched under his boots. Frozen.
He looked down at himself. Mud to the knees. His rain jacket, the county one, dark with wet across the shoulders, and the wet was stiffening. He put his hand on it. Ice. A thin skin of it on the nylon, cracking when he moved.
He’d gone in at ten at night. In April. In the rain.
He turned around and looked at the tree line. The hemlocks stood there black-green and still with frost on their outer needles, and the old skid road went in under them like a mouth, and in under there it was dark. Just dark. No sound of water. Nothing.
He reached for his belt.
The spare handheld was there, where he’d clipped it in April without thinking about it, the old Motorola from the console of the Tahoe that he kept for when his shoulder radio died. He’d given his good one to Bev. He’d forgotten he had this one. He unclipped it. The battery light was green. Full. He looked at it for a while. Then he keyed it.
“Rusk,” he said. His voice came out of him rusty. “Coming back in.”
Static. A long hiss. He stood on the frozen gravel with the radio to his face and waited.
Then a voice. A young man’s voice. Not Bev. Not Tyler Shook on nights. Nobody he knew.
“Unit calling, say again?”
“This is Rusk. Sheriff Rusk. I’m at the Voss landing above Hale Gap. I’m coming back in.”
The hiss went on a long time.
“Sir,” the voice said, carefully, like talking to a drunk on the phone. “Sheriff Hargrove isn’t taking calls right now. Who is this?”
Daniel stood there with the radio in his hand and his breath going up white in front of his face.2He went down through the poplars. His legs didn’t want to work right. They were stiff, like he’d slept on the ground, which he supposed he had. The pasture behind Annie Ross’s double-wide was white with frost and his boots broke through the top of it and left dark tracks behind him.
The gate at the bottom was shut. He climbed it.
Lena’s Charger was parked behind the double-wide where she’d left it. Gray. With state plates. He walked over to it.
Leaves had drifted against all four tires. Oak leaves, brown, a foot deep on the uphill side, banked against the rubber like snow against a fence. There was a skin of pollen on the windshield under the frost, yellow, from April and May. He wiped a place with his sleeve and looked in. Her coffee cup in the console. A legal pad on the passenger seat. Her reading glasses folded on top of it.
He tried the door. Locked.
He stood there with his hand on the handle and looked at the leaves banked against the tires and the pollen on the glass, and he thought about how long it takes leaves to bank up that deep, and he made himself stop thinking about it.
The Tahoe was gone. He’d parked it right beside her. There was a rectangle in the grass where it had sat, pale, the grass flattened and yellow and coming back green at the edges.
He went around to the front of the double-wide.
The porch light was on. The curtains were drawn. There was a wreath on the door. A Christmas wreath, real, with a red bow on it, and pine cones wired into it, and a little wooden sign hanging in the middle that said JOY.
He looked at the wreath a long time.
He knocked.
Nothing. Then footsteps. Slow ones. Uneven. A man’s. They came to the door and stopped, and Daniel heard somebody stand there on the other side of the door for a while, breathing, the way you stand when you’re not sure you want to open a door.
The door opened.
Walter Hale stood there in a flannel shirt and long johns and his sock feet, with his gray hair sticking up on one side. He looked at Daniel. He looked at him from his boots to his face, the mud and the iced jacket, and he didn’t say anything. His face didn’t do anything. It was the face from the tree line in November, when Daniel had asked would the road open for him. Weather.
Then Walter stepped out onto the porch in his sock feet on the frozen boards and sat down on the top step. Just sat. Like his legs had quit. And he put his face in his hands.
Daniel stood in the door.
He’d never seen Walter Hale do anything like that. In his whole life. He stood there and looked at the old man’s back, at his shoulders in the flannel shirt, and they didn’t shake, and Walter didn’t make a sound. He just sat there with his face in his big hands.
“Walter,” Daniel said.
Walter didn’t look up.
“What day is it?”
For a long time Walter didn’t answer. Then he took his hands away from his face and looked out at the yard, at the frost, at the mailbox at the end of the drive with a little drift of frozen leaves around its post.
“Tuesday,” he said. “The ninth.”
“Of what?”
Walter looked at him then.
“December,” he said.
Annie made coffee. She didn’t say anything either. She came out of the back of the house in a bathrobe and saw Daniel standing in her kitchen and put her hand over her mouth and stood like that, and then she went to the coffee maker and started making coffee with her back to him, and her hands were shaking so bad she spilled the grounds.
Daniel sat at the kitchen table. Walter sat across from him. Neither of them said anything for a while.
Daniel put his hand on his shirt pocket.
He did it without thinking. He’d been doing it for a year. He unbuttoned the flap and put two fingers in. The ring was there. He felt the stone. He felt the band, warm from his body. He took it out and set it on the kitchen table.
He put his fingers back in the pocket.
Empty.
He felt around the bottom of it. He turned it inside out, there at the table, pulled the lining out of his shirt like a man looking for a lost key, and looked at it. Lint. A crumb of something. A thread. Nothing else.
He put it back. He took it out again. He turned it inside out a second time, and looked at it again, longer.
“What?” Walter said.
“Tommy’s badge,” Daniel said. “It was here. With the ring. It was right here in this pocket when I went in.”
Walter looked at the ring on the table. He didn’t touch it.
“What else do you remember,” he said.
Daniel looked at the ring.
He remembered pieces. That was all. Pieces, like you’d remember a dream if somebody woke you in the middle of it. He remembered the gate. He remembered Margaret Bell’s hand, which was cool and dry and smaller than he’d thought, taking hold of his. He remembered yes ma’am coming out of his mouth. He remembered Lena’s fingers digging into his arm, and then letting go, and then he couldn’t feel them anymore, and he’d turned his head and she was gone off down the side of the church into the crowd by the long table, fast, toward somebody, a man with his back to them, gray at the temples. She’d been running.
He remembered the table. White cloths. The smell of it. Fried chicken and pie and coffee. Somebody holding a plate out to him.
He hadn’t taken it. He was sure of that. He was as sure of that as he was of his own name. He remembered standing there with a plate held out to him and his hands at his sides, and his stomach turning over, and not taking it.
He remembered Margaret’s face, close. Gray eyes. Her mouth near his ear.
Not yet, she’d said. Go home and tell Silas.
And then the tree line. Lying on his back in the leaves at the edge of the hemlocks with frost on his face. Dawn. The cold.
That was all.
“I didn’t eat,” he said.
“I know you didn’t,” Walter said. “You wouldn’t be sitting here.”
“Lena…”
“She didn’t come out.” Walter looked at his hands on the table. “I stood at that line till it got light. Then I went down and got Annie to call Bev. Then I went back up and stood there another day. And the next night.” He turned his coffee cup a quarter turn. “Then I come back every night after that. Most nights. Till about August. Then I quit.” He looked at Daniel. “I’m sorry, Danny. I quit.”
“Eight months.”
“Eight months tomorrow.”
Annie set a cup of coffee down in front of Daniel. She put her hand on his shoulder for a second, very light, and took it away, and went back to the counter and stood there with her back to them.
Daniel looked at the coffee. He picked it up. His hands were cold and the cup was hot, and he held it in both of them and didn’t drink it.
“Walter,” he said. “Who’s been running the county?”
Walter looked at him a long time.
“You’d better go see Bev,” he said.3Bev cried first.
She was at the dispatch console when he came in the side door of the annex at eight-fifteen, in his iced jacket, with mud to the knee, in Annie’s car because Annie had driven him. Bev looked up from the console. She took her headset off. She looked at him for a long time over her glasses.
Then she put her face down on the console, on her arms, right on top of the keyboard, so the screen filled up with a long line of the letter j, and cried.
He’d never seen her cry. Not at his daddy’s funeral. Not when her husband left. Not in 2004 when the river took the Bell Road bridge with a family in a minivan on it. He stood in the doorway of the dispatch room and didn’t know what to do, and after a while he went over and put his hand on her back, between her shoulder blades, and left it there.
Then she sat up. She wiped her face with both hands, hard. She took off her glasses and wiped them on her sweater and put them back on.
“I’ll make coffee,” she said.
She told it in order, because that was how Bev told things.
April. He’d gone up. Lena had gone up. Walter had stood at the line. Pruitt had held the county through the storm, and Coy had come in at dawn as acting, because Daniel had said so, and nobody had argued. A week. Two weeks. The SBI came. A state search team on the Voss landing for ten days, with dogs and a drone and the Swain County rescue squad. The dogs had stopped at the tree line. Every one. The drone had flown over the hemlocks and found nothing. The search team had gone in a hundred yards on the old skid road and hit laurel and rock.
“They did the creek,” Bev said. “They did the river all the way to Fontana. They did the mine shafts on Laurel Knob with a camera on a rope.” She was holding her coffee in both hands. “Nothing. Not a shoe. Not a button.”
May. June. The commissioners had a meeting. Then another. Royce Ammons said the county couldn’t run forever on an acting sheriff with no authority to sign a contract or a check. Faye Hargrove Pruitt found something in the courthouse basement.
“The 1931 local act,” Bev said. “You ever heard of it?”
“No.”
“Nobody had. Doris found it. In a box. In the legislature’s session laws for 1931, chapter something, a local bill for Blackwater County.” Bev set her cup down. “Seems in 1930 the sheriff went missing. Sheriff Kincaid. Went up the Bell lease after a moonshiner and never come back. And the county didn’t have anybody who could sign the payroll for a year. So the legislature passed a law. Just for us. If the sheriff’s absent more than a hundred and eighty days without explanation, the commissioners appoint an acting sheriff, and the office goes to a special election within twelve months.”
Daniel sat there.
“A hundred and eighty days was October the fifth,” Bev said. “They met on the sixth. Four to one. Coralee Hensley voted no and made a speech about it. They appointed Coy.” She looked at him over her glasses. “The election’s set for June.”
“Coy,” Daniel said.
“Acting Sheriff Coy Hargrove.” Bev said it like she was reading off a lab result. “He’s in your office. He’s had it painted. And he put down new carpet.”
Coy was courteous.
That was the worst of it. Daniel had expected something else. He’d expected Coy to gloat, or bluster, or put his hand on his sidearm. He walked down the hall to his own office at nine o’clock and the door was open and Coy was behind his desk, Daniel’s desk, which had been his daddy’s desk, in a pressed uniform with ACTING SHERIFF on a brass bar over the pocket. And when he saw Daniel in the door he stood up, and came around the desk, and put out his hand.
“Daniel,” Coy said. “Thank God.”
Daniel looked at the hand.
“We looked for you,” Coy said. “Everybody did. I want you to know that. I had every man I had on that mountain for two weeks.” He kept his hand out. “Whatever happened up there, I’m glad you’re back. I mean that.”
Daniel shook his hand. It was dry and strong and it let go first.
The office was blue. It had been beige for as long as Daniel had been alive. His daddy’s beige. Now it was a pale gray-blue, a color off a paint chip with a name like Harbor Mist, and there was new carpet, gray, the commercial kind with a little fleck in it, and the smell of both of them was still in the air, glue and latex. The desk was the same. The chair was new. On the wall where Daniel’s daddy’s photograph had hung, Ward Rusk in 1967 being sworn in, there was a framed print of an eagle.
“You’ll want to talk to the commissioners,” Coy said. “And the SBI. And your lawyer, I’d think.” He went back around the desk and sat down in the new chair. He didn’t ask Daniel to sit. “I’ll have Bev set it up. Take whatever time you need.”
“Where are my boxes?”
“Your boxes?”
“In the storage room. Forty-one banker’s boxes and a folding table. My brother’s files.”
Coy looked at him pleasantly.
“The commissioners ordered that room cleared in July,” he said. “For the new evidence storage. Those were personal effects, Daniel. They weren’t county property. We didn’t know if you were coming back.” He picked up a pen. “They’re in the old jail basement, I believe. With some other things. You’re welcome to them.”
Daniel stood in the door of his office that was blue now and looked at Coy Hargrove behind his daddy’s desk.
“I’ll be running,” he said. “In June.”
Coy smiled. It was a nice smile. He’d had it his whole life. Everybody in his family had it.
“I’d expect nothing less,” he said.
He walked to his cousin’s house on Laurel Fork Road because he didn’t have a car.
It was two miles. It was nine degrees out, according to the bank clock on Depot Street. He walked it in his iced jacket with his hands in his pockets and his breath going up white, and people looked at him. People in cars. People on the sidewalk in front of the hardware store. Somebody honked. Somebody slowed down and stared and then sped up. He kept walking.
Lynn was at work. Her dog met him at the porch, a big yellow mutt named Biscuit that had slept across his boots every night for six months, and it stopped at the bottom of the steps and looked at him and put its hackles up.
He stood there.
“Biscuit,” he said.
The dog looked at him. It growled, very low, more in its chest than its throat. Then it stopped. Then it came up the steps sideways, sniffing, and smelled his boots, his knees, his hands, for a long time, like it was reading something written on him, and then it sat down at his feet and leaned against his legs and stayed there.
He found the papers on the dresser in his room.
A big envelope from the law firm in Sylva, opened. Lynn must have opened it, or the post office, or somebody. Inside: a complaint for absolute divorce. Served by certified mail in September to his last known address. A copy of the judgment. Granted, Blackwater County District Court, November 14th. One year’s separation. Uncontested.
He sat on the edge of the bed and read it. All of it. Every page. It didn’t take long. North Carolina made it simple when there wasn’t anything to fight about. There hadn’t been anything to fight about. He’d left her the house. He’d left her everything.
At the bottom of the envelope there was a sticky note, yellow, in Carrie’s slanting hand.
I didn’t know if you were alive. I’m sorry. I didn’t know what else to do. C.
She called at eleven that night.
He was lying on the bed in his cousin’s back room with the light off and the dog asleep across the foot of the bed, looking at the ceiling. His phone was on the nightstand. Lynn had plugged it in for him; it had been dead eight months. It rang.
He looked at the screen. He looked at it a long time.
“Carrie.”
Nothing on the line. Breathing. He could hear her kitchen. The refrigerator. The clock on the wall, the one that ticked loud, that she’d bought at the craft fair in Dillsboro in 2008. He knew every sound in that kitchen. He’d lived in it twenty-two years.
She didn’t say anything.
He didn’t either. He lay there with the phone to his ear and the dog’s weight on his feet, and she sat in her kitchen on Hickory Knob, and neither of them said a word. He didn’t know how long. A long time. Long enough that he heard the clock on her wall go around to the hour and the little click it made.
Then she said, “Okay.”
That was all. Just okay. The same as she’d said on the phone in April. Okay. Okay.
And she hung up.
Dana Whitlock called at seven the next morning.
He’d never met her. He knew her voice from Lena’s phone calls, from across a booth at the Grill. Brisk and dry and a little tired.
“Sheriff Rusk,” she said. “I understand you’re back.”
“I’m back.”
“And Lena?”
“No.”
The line was quiet a long time.
“I’ve had an open missing-person file on her since April twenty-second,” Dana said. “State Bureau of Investigation case number 27-0614. Lena Mercer, thirty-two, former SBI agent, last seen entering a wooded area above Hale Gap, Blackwater County, in the company of the county sheriff, who was also missing.” A pause. “I’m going to need a statement from you, Sheriff. In person. I’ll drive over.”
“All right.”
“Was she alive? When you last saw her?”
Daniel thought about Lena running down the side of the church toward a man with gray at his temples. Running like a child.
“Yes,” he said.
“Do you know where she is?”
He looked at the ceiling of his cousin’s back room.
“No ma’am,” he said.
Dana was quiet again.
“Her father,” she said. “Frank Mercer. That was 2001, right? Same place?”
“Yes.”
“I was a rookie,” Dana said. “In 2001. Hal Brookshire’s office. I filed the paper on Frank.” Another pause. “I never thought I’d file the same paper on his daughter. Out of the same county. Twenty-six years later.” Her voice didn’t change, but something under it did. “I told her not to go out there, Sheriff. I told her she was too close.”
“I know you did.”
“She didn’t listen.”
“No ma’am,” Daniel said. “She didn’t.”4He went to the Grill on Thursday because he was hungry and because he didn’t know what else to do with a Thursday morning when you weren’t anybody.
He’d thought about not going. He’d thought about how everybody would look at him. He’d decided he didn’t care. He walked in at six-forty and the bell over the door rang and every head at the counter and in the booths came around, and he stood there in his own jacket, the brown canvas one, because the county one was county property and Coy had sent a deputy to Lynn’s for it on Wednesday, very politely.
Nobody said anything.
He went to the counter. He sat on the stool at the end, where he always sat. Pauline came down the counter with the pot. She was sixty-something, with her gray hair in a bun and a pencil stuck through it, and she’d been pouring his coffee since he was nineteen years old.
She poured his coffee. Then she looked at him.
“Same as every Tuesday?” she said.
He looked at her.
“It’s Thursday,” he said.
“I know what day it is, Danny.” She set the pot down on the counter. “I’m asking you do you want the same as every Tuesday. Two over. No toast. You never want toast.”
He sat there.
He’d eaten toast at this counter every morning of his life. Wheat toast, with the little packets of grape jelly. He’d eaten it since before Pauline started here. He didn’t know anybody who ate eggs without toast.
“Pauline,” he said. “I haven’t been here.”
“You’ve been here every Tuesday since April.”
“Pauline.”
“Every Tuesday.” She was looking at him with her hand flat on the counter next to the coffee pot. “You come in at six-thirty. You set right there where you’re setting. You order two eggs over, no toast, and coffee, black, and you eat it and you don’t say two words, and you pay and you leave.” She looked at him. “I asked you once where you’d been. In May. Everybody was looking for you. Half the county was up on that mountain. And you come in and set down and I said Danny, Lord, where have you been, everybody’s out of their mind. And you looked at me and didn’t say nothing. You just ate your eggs.” She was very quiet. “So I quit asking.”
The Grill was quiet. Daniel could feel it. Everybody at the counter listening.
“Earl,” Pauline said. “Tell him.”
Earl Dockery was three stools down, with his cane hooked on the counter. He looked at Daniel. He looked at him a long time.
“I seen you,” Earl said. His hearing aid whistled. “Tuesdays. Right there.” He frowned. “Didn’t I?”
“You did,” Pauline said.
“I did.” Earl looked at his coffee. “I thought I did. I thought it was you. I remember thinking it was strange you didn’t say nothing to nobody. You always say something.” He looked at Daniel again. “I remember thinking your hair was different.”
“Different how?”
Earl opened his mouth. Shut it. “I don’t know,” he said. “Combed. Like somebody’d combed it for you.”
One of the Ledford boys at the end of the counter said, “I never seen him.”
“You never come in on Tuesday, Wesley.”
“I come in on Tuesday some.”
“Then you seen him.”
“I didn’t, though,” the Ledford boy said. He looked at Daniel, and then away. “I don’t think I did.”
Pauline went to the register. She opened the drawer under it, the one where she kept the old receipts in rubber bands, and dug through it, and came back with a slip of paper. A credit card receipt. The carbon kind, from the old machine she still used for people whose cards didn’t have the chip, which was Daniel. She laid it on the counter in front of him.
BLACKWATER GRILL. 08/12. 06:47. $7.43. His card number, the last four digits. And a signature.
D. Rusk.
He looked at it.
It was his signature. The D, with the loop at the top. The R. The little line he drew under the whole thing that he’d started doing in the sixth grade because he’d seen a ballplayer do it on a baseball card. All of it. His.
And under the signature, where the tip went, somebody had written the number. $1.57. So the total came to nine.
The seven in the 1.57 didn’t have a line through it.
Daniel crossed his sevens. He’d crossed them since Mrs. Teague in the second grade made him, because she said an uncrossed seven looked like a one and she’d marked him wrong on a spelling test for a seven she read as a one, and he’d cried about it at supper, and his daddy had said cross your sevens, son, and you’ll never get marked wrong again. Forty-four years. Every seven he’d ever written.
He looked at the uncrossed seven a long time.
“That’s me,” Pauline said. “Right? That’s you. That’s your name.”
“That’s my name,” Daniel said.
He paid for his coffee. He crossed the seven in the tip. He walked out. Behind him, in the Grill, he heard the bell over the door, and then nobody said anything for a long time.
Eli Voss was on his porch in a wool coat with a quilt over his knees and a thermos of coffee, though it was eleven degrees, like a man who’d been told somebody was coming and had come out to wait.
Daniel came up the steps. He didn’t wait to be asked. He sat down on the top one, below Eli’s rocker, with his back against the post.
He told it. All of it. The landing and the road and the valley. The gate. Margaret. The table. The plate held out to him. Lena running. Not yet. The frost. Walter on the steps. The badge gone. Pauline and the Tuesdays. The seven.
Eli listened. He didn’t say anything the whole time. He drank his coffee from the thermos cap, slow, and looked out at his garden, the tomato cages leaning in the frost, the dead vines black on the wire.
When Daniel was done Eli set the thermos cap down on the porch rail, handle out.
“You answered,” he said.
Daniel looked up at him.
“I didn’t say that.”
“You didn’t have to.” Eli looked down at him. His old face. The long Voss jaw. “I’ve seen men come out of those woods, Danny. Three in my life. Walter. A Shook boy in 1983 that died in a month. And now you.” He looked at the garden. “And I’ve heard the old people talk. My granddaddy. His mama. What they said. And you come up my steps with your hair combed different, and a fella at the Grill been eating your eggs on Tuesdays and signing your name.” He was quiet. “You answered.”
Daniel didn’t say anything for a while.
“She said my name,” he said. “My whole name. At the gate. And I said yes ma’am.”
Eli nodded.
“What does it mean?” Daniel said. “Answering. What did I do?”
“I don’t know.”
“Eli.”
“I don’t know, son. Nobody knows. That’s the God’s truth.” Eli picked the thermos cap back up and looked into it. “My granddaddy used to say, you answer your name over there, you give something of yourself to it. A piece. He said it’s like signing a paper you didn’t read.” He drank. “That’s all he said. He didn’t say what piece.”
Daniel sat on the step.
He thought about the receipt. His signature. His name, in his own hand. Signed by somebody who’d never had a second-grade teacher named Mrs. Teague.
“Something’s been walking around in this county with my face on,” he said. “For eight months. Eating eggs. Signing my name.”
Eli didn’t say anything.
“Where is it now?”
Eli looked at the tree line at the edge of his garden. The woods, gray and bare in the cold. He looked at it a long time.
“Danny,” he said. “I’d guess it went home when you did.”5Silas Bell received him in the study with the fire lit and a glass of bourbon he didn’t offer, and didn’t sit down.
Daniel stood inside the door. He hadn’t been invited to sit either. He’d driven up the three miles of paved road in Lynn’s Buick, which she’d lent him, which smelled like her cigarettes and her dog, and he’d parked under the oaks in front of the house and Mrs. Ammons had let him in without a word and walked him down the long hall past the portrait.
He hadn’t looked at the portrait. He’d felt it look at him.
“Sheriff,” Silas said. “Or… I’m sorry. I don’t know what to call you.”
“Daniel.”
“Daniel.” Silas was standing by the fire with the glass. He looked older. Much older. He’d looked sixty-two in April. He looked seventy now. There was gray stubble on his jaw, which Daniel had never once seen in thirty years, and his tie was loose. “They told me you were back. I didn’t believe it. I’ve been waiting for you to come up that road since Tuesday morning.”
“She sent me,” Daniel said.
Silas didn’t move.
“Margaret,” Daniel said. “At the gate. She took my hand. She said my name and I…” He stopped. “I answered her. And afterward. At the end. She said two things to me.” He looked at Silas. “She said not yet. And she said go home and tell Silas.”
The fire popped.
Silas Bell sat down.
He didn’t sit in a chair. He sat on the edge of the hearth, on the stone, by the fire, all at once, like a man whose knees have been kicked out from under him. The glass of bourbon tipped in his hand and some of it went on the hearthstones and he didn’t notice. He sat there on the hearth with his elbows on his knees and the glass hanging from his fingers and looked at the rug.
“Tell me what?” he said.
“That’s all she said.”
“Tell me what, Daniel?”
“That’s all. Go home and tell Silas. Then I was at the tree line and it was December.”
Silas looked at the rug.
“Not yet,” he said, to the rug. “Not yet.” He said it over, slow, like a man trying out a word in a language he’d studied his whole life and never heard spoken. “Not yet what? Not yet for whom? Is that for you? For me? For her?” He looked up. “For the girl?”
“I don’t know.”
“Fifty-seven years,” Silas said. “Fifty-seven years she’s stood at the edge of my lawn. She’s said two sentences to me in my whole life. And she sends me a message by the sheriff.” He laughed. It was a terrible sound. “Tell Silas.”
He set the glass down on the hearthstone. He put his face in his hands.
Daniel stood inside the door of the study.
He thought about Walter on the porch step on Tuesday morning, with his face in his hands. He thought about Bev with her face on the keyboard. He thought that was three people in three days he’d seen put their faces in their hands, and he’d never in his life before this week seen a grown person do it, and he didn’t know what that meant, and he thought about it longer than he should have, standing there in Silas Bell’s study with the fire going, and he couldn’t stop.
“Mr. Bell,” he said. “Is there anything you need me to do?”
Silas took his hands away from his face. He looked at Daniel from the hearthstone.
“Go home,” he said. “Like she told you.”
The old jail was behind the courthouse on Depot Street, a two-story brick box from 1912 with bars still on the upstairs windows. The county had used it for storage since the new detention center went in under the annex in 1988. The basement flooded every spring. Everybody knew it flooded. You didn’t put paper in the old jail basement.
They’d put the boxes there.
He found them at ten o’clock at night with Lynn’s flashlight, in the back corner, past the old voting machines and the Christmas decorations and a stack of folding chairs from the Ruritan. Forty-one banker’s boxes, stacked any which way, some on their sides. The bottom row had been sitting in water. You could see the line. A brown stain running across every box at the same height, eight inches up, where the water had stood in April and May. The cardboard was soft below the line. Some of it had split.
He didn’t call anybody. He didn’t get a dolly. He picked up the first box.
It was heavy. Wet paper is heavy. He carried it up the basement stairs, eleven steps, concrete, with a pipe rail on one side, and out the back door into the cold, and across the gravel lot to Lynn’s Buick, and put it in the back seat. Then he went back down.
He did it forty-one times.
He didn’t count at first. Then he did. He counted the stairs. Eleven. He counted the steps across the lot. Twenty-six, from the jail door to the Buick. He counted the boxes. Around fifteen the back seat was full and he started on the trunk. Around twenty-five the trunk was full and he started stacking them on the gravel by the car, in rows, the dry ones on top, the wet ones on the bottom.
It was very cold. His breath went up white in the light over the jail door every time he came out. The town was asleep. Once a car went by on Depot Street, slow, and didn’t stop. Once a dog barked somewhere over toward Church Hill, and kept barking, the same two notes, for a long time, and then quit.
Box thirty-three had split all the way down one side. When he picked it up the side gave out and the folders inside slid out onto the basement floor. In the flashlight he saw the tabs. 1984. 1985. 1986. The box Walter had sat on, dripping, in October, the morning he brought the ring. The Shook barn fire. The Teague boy at the quarry. Bev’s labels, in her careful printing, had run in the wet and gone blue and soft, and the folders were stuck together, and the paper inside them was gray and wavy, and some of the ink had come off the pages entirely and was just gone. Pages with nothing on them but a faint gray stain where words had been.
He knelt on the wet concrete and picked them up one at a time and put them back in the box. He held the split side together with his hand. He carried it up the stairs that way, eleven steps, with one hand holding the box shut, and his knees hurting, and the flashlight in his teeth.
He didn’t know why he didn’t just leave them. He thought about it, on the stairs, the thirtieth time, the thirty-fifth. He thought he could leave them. They were copies. Most of them. Evan’s copies of county records that were still in the courthouse, or had been. Newspaper clippings you could get on microfilm at the library in Sylva. Maps you could buy. He could leave every one of them in the old jail basement and go home and sleep, and he wouldn’t have lost anything that couldn’t be found again.
He kept carrying them.
The last one was the laminated flyer. It wasn’t in a box. Somebody had leaned it against the wall behind the boxes, face out, like they hadn’t known what to do with it either. MISSING. EVAN THOMAS RUSK. AGE 18. The water had come up under the laminate at the bottom edge and there was a brown stain creeping up from the corner, across LAST SEEN SEPTEMBER 21, 1996, into the bottom of the picture, Evan’s jaw, his chin. The rest of his face was fine. The grin. The hair he’d been told to cut.
Daniel picked it up and carried it out to the car and laid it face up on top of the boxes in the back seat.
It was two-thirty in the morning. He sat in the driver’s seat of Lynn’s Buick in the lot behind the old jail with the engine running and the heater going and forty-one boxes of his brother around him, in the back seat and the trunk and stacked on the gravel outside in the cold, and he didn’t drive anywhere. He sat there until the windows fogged.6Ray Baker came to find him on Friday.
Daniel was in Lynn’s garage, where he’d stacked the boxes along the back wall to dry, with a box fan going and a space heater and the garage door cracked a foot to let the damp out. He was going through box thirty-three on a card table, peeling the stuck folders apart one page at a time with a putty knife, and laying the pages out on the concrete floor in rows to dry, when Ray’s white Ford pulled into the drive.
Ray got out. He stood at the edge of the garage door with his hands in his jacket pockets, as he’d stood at the edge of his own garage, Daniel would learn later, when Preston Caldwell came.
“Sheriff,” Ray said.
“Ray. I’m not sheriff.”
“You’re the sheriff,” Ray said. “I don’t care what Coy Hargrove’s got on his pocket.” He came in and looked at the pages laid out on the floor in rows. He looked at them a long time, like a machinist looking at parts on a bench. “You’re drying them.”
“Trying to.”
“You’ll want to put weight on them. When they’re about half dry. Books. Or a board. Else they’ll curl.” Ray looked at the box fan. “And turn that fan down. You’re blowing ’em around.”
Daniel turned the fan down.
Ray stood there with his hands in his pockets.
“Mama died,” he said.
Daniel set down the putty knife.
“October. The twenty-second.” Ray said it plain. “In her chair by the window. Pam found her in the morning. The nurse said it was in the night, in her sleep, she didn’t feel nothing.” He looked at the pages on the floor. “She was sitting up in the chair, though. Not in the bed. Pam said she had her hand up on the glass.”
“I’m sorry, Ray.”
“I know you are.” Ray took his hands out of his pockets and looked at them. “That ain’t why I come. I mean, it is. I wanted you to know. You was gone, and nobody’d have told you.” He put his hands back. “But that ain’t the main thing.”
Daniel waited.
“The woman,” Ray said. “At the nursing home. In the coat.”
“The camel coat.”
Ray looked at him. “How’d you know it was camel?”
“Lena told me. Before. About the archive.”
Ray nodded slowly.
“Mama seen her a year ago December,” he said. “The night I went to the archive and come out. Mama told me about it the next week. Said she was at the tree line past the parking lot. Looking at my truck.” He looked at the boxes along the wall. “I didn’t believe her. I figured it was the stroke.”
“And now?”
“Pam’s seen her,” Ray said. “Three times since spring. At the tree line. Same place. Same coat. Pam works nights now. She said she’ll be on the floor at two in the morning, and she’ll look out the window at the end of the hall, and there she’ll be. Standing at the edge of the trees. Looking at the building.” He was quiet. “Twice before Mama died. Once after.”
“After.”
“The night after the funeral,” Ray said. “Pam said she was standing right there. Looking up at Mama’s window. At the empty room.” He took a breath. “Pam said she had her hand up to her mouth. Like this.” He put his hand flat over his mouth, and held it there, and took it away. “Pam said she stood like that till it got light.”
Daniel looked at the pages on the floor.
“Preston been back?” he asked.
“Twice.” Ray’s face went hard. “Sent a lawyer once. Sent flowers to the funeral. A big wreath, white roses, with a card. With deepest sympathy, the Caldwell family. I put it in the creek behind the house.” He looked at Daniel. “He ain’t give up, Sheriff. He sent a letter last month. Typed. Said the offer stands. Said the archive door is always open. Said, your mother is waiting.”
“Which mother?”
Ray looked at him.
“That’s what I said,” he said. “That’s exactly what I said out loud, standing in my kitchen reading it. Which mother.”
The Blackwater County Board of Elections was a room on the ground floor of the courthouse with a counter and a flag and a woman named Doris Ammons behind the counter, who was also the deputy clerk of court, and the register of deeds on Thursdays, and had been doing one or all of those things since 1981.
Doris looked at Daniel over her reading glasses on their beaded chain.
“Danny,” she said.
“Miss Doris.”
“I heard.” She looked at him a while longer. “Lord, I heard.” She took off her glasses and let them drop on the chain. “You want to file.”
“I want to file.”
She got the form out of a drawer without looking for it. She’d had it ready, he understood. She’d had it in that drawer since October. She laid it on the counter and turned it around to face him and set a pen on it.
He filled it out. Name. Address, which was Lynn’s. Office sought. Sheriff, Blackwater County. Party affiliation. He signed it at the bottom.
D. Rusk, with the loop at the top of the D and the line underneath.
He dated it. 12/12. There wasn’t a seven in it. He looked at the date for a while anyway.
Doris took the form back. She read it, every line, as she read everything. She stamped it. RECEIVED. The date.
“Filing fee’s a hundred and seventy-two dollars,” she said.
He paid it. In cash, from his wallet, from money Lynn had loaned him. Doris wrote him a receipt by hand in a receipt book with carbons. Received of D. Rusk the sum of $172.00.
She looked at the seven in 172. She’d crossed it. She’d crossed every seven she’d ever written, the same as he had. Mrs. Teague had had her too, in 1962.
She tore off the receipt and handed it to him.
“Good luck, honey,” Doris said. “You’ll need it.”7On Tuesday morning Pauline Hensley came in to open at five-thirty like she’d done for thirty-one years, and turned on the grill, and made the first pot, and stood at the window by the register with her coffee watching Depot Street get light, and at six-twenty-nine the bell over the door rang and Daniel Rusk came in.
He sat at the end of the counter. On the stool he always sat on.
She came down with the pot. She poured. She stood there.
“Two eggs over,” Daniel said. “No toast.”
She looked at him.
He was looking at her. He wasn’t smiling. It wasn’t a joke. She could see it wasn’t. He was sitting there in his brown canvas jacket with his hands around the cup, and his hair was standing up in back where it always stood up, uncombed, and he was looking at her very steady, like a man asking her a question he couldn’t say out loud.
“No toast,” she said.
“No toast.”
She made them herself. She didn’t hand it to the cook. She cracked the eggs on the flat top and turned them with the spatula and slid them onto a plate, two over, the yolks just set, and carried it down the counter and set it in front of him.
He ate them.
She stood by the coffee pot and watched him. She didn’t mean to. She wiped the counter. She filled the sugar. She watched him. He ate slow, cutting the eggs with the side of his fork, the way he’d always eaten, and once he looked up at the window behind her where you could see Depot Street, and looked at it a long time, and went back to eating.
He didn’t say anything to anybody. The Ledford boy came in at six-forty and said, “Sheriff,” and Daniel nodded and that was all.
He finished. He put a ten on the counter and stood up and put on his hat.
“Thank you, Pauline,” he said.
That was different. The other one had never said thank you. Not once. Eight months of Tuesdays.
He went out. The bell over the door rang. She watched him through the window walk down Depot Street toward the courthouse with his hands in his pockets and his breath going up white.
She went down the counter to clear his plate.
It was clean. He’d eaten every bite. She picked it up.
Under the edge of the plate, on the counter, where the rim had been, there was something.
She looked at it a while before she picked it up.
A badge. Old. A deputy’s star, seven points, nickel-plated, the plating worn off the tips so the brass showed through, gone dark. A pin on the back. A number in the middle.
It was cold. Colder than it ought to be, sitting on a counter in a diner with the grill going. Cold like it had been outside all night. Like it had been somewhere a long way off and just come in.
Pauline stood there holding it in her palm.
She looked at the door. At Depot Street through the window, empty now, getting light. She looked at the stool at the end of the counter where he’d sat, and where the other one had sat every Tuesday since April, eating his eggs with no toast and never saying thank you.
She didn’t know which one had left it.
She closed her hand around it. It was so cold it hurt. She stood there in the Grill at a quarter to seven on a Tuesday morning in December holding it, until it was as warm as her hand, and then she put it in her apron pocket, and went and got the coffee pot, and went down the counter to see about Earl.