அத்தியாயம் 11: IAW Vol 2 Ch 24 (Whose Fault)IAW தொ.2 அ.24 (யாருடைய தவறு)

இந்த அத்தியாயம் இன்னும் Tamil மொழியில் கிடைக்கவில்லை. உள்நுழைந்து மொழிபெயர்த்து அனைவருக்கும் கிடைக்கச் செய்யுங்கள்.

At home, whenever a counter had to close, someone put up a sign. It was always the same sign, printed and laminated, kept in a drawer for the purpose. Mohon maaf atas ketidaknyamanannya. We apologize for the inconvenience.

I had always thought it was a polite sign. I wrote it out on the morning of Day 248, in Lorvane, on a sheet of Corvin's ruled paper, to hang over the door on the street of goldsmiths. Then I looked at it for a long time.

It wasn't an inconvenience. An inconvenience is a broken pen, or a long queue, or a teller on her lunch break. This was fifty-four crowns and twelve marks that had not been ours to lose.

I crossed it out, and wrote underneath:

We lost 54 crowns, 12 marks of this house's coin, through our own officer. Not one bit of it was yours. Your coin is counted. Ask me anything. S. Halim, keeper.

Corvin read it over my shoulder. He didn't take my pen. He nodded once, and went downstairs to unbar the door.

They came in a long, uneasy line, the people of Aubrelle, holding their wooden tokens the way you hold a ticket for a ship you are no longer sure is seaworthy. The wine merchant was first. He wanted every bit of his eleven crowns, in his hand, and I counted them out in front of him, twice, and he put them in a leather bag and left without looking at me, and I didn't blame him at all.

By noon, nine more had done the same. I paid every one in full. I apologized to every one, in words, not with a laminated sign. Some of them said it was all right. Some of them didn't say anything. One woman spat on the step on her way out, very accurately, and Wat considered the spit for a long moment and then went and fetched a bucket.

Abel Thorne came at the third bell. He took his token, waited his turn, and put both enormous hands flat on my counter.

"Saw you count a hundred crowns on a tailboard," he said. "Twice. In front of everybody." He looked at my sign. "Now you've written down in front of everybody that you lost fifty-four." He thought about it, red-faced and frowning. "I never met anybody who'd do both."

He took his passbook back without drawing a single bit, and went out.

Old Master Fulk Arden came very slowly at the fifth bell, with his loupe on its cord, and read my sign through it from a distance of two inches.

"Miss Halim," he said, "I have been robbed by a baron, by the baron's creditors, and by my own nephew, who took the good scales." He let the loupe drop. "I have been robbed by far better liars than you. Not one of them ever wrote it on the door."

He kept his three marks where they were.

By the end of Day 249, eleven depositors had closed their accounts and twenty-three crowns had walked out of the vault, every one of them owed. Twenty-two stayed. Gil Harker stayed, loudly. So did Wenna, the cooper's wife, who came in with her baby on her hip to tell me that her father would have her hide if she took her money out of the Sekka, and who did not seem to notice the word she had used, and I did not correct her.

Correction number two hundred and twenty-eight, I thought. Pending.

That night, Corvin and I wrote thirteen correction rows into the Aubrelle ledger. One for each account from down the road, each one setting the balance back to the few bits that its holder had actually put in with their own hand on the day they opened it. We didn't erase anything. We never do. Every fictitious row stayed exactly where Lotte had written it, sealed in gold, and directly underneath it, in the next row, the truth.

Then there was the question of the door.

We couldn't keep it. That was the plain fact, and Corvin made me say it out loud before he would talk about anything else. There was no one to hold a stamp. Corvin wouldn't, and was right not to. Wat couldn't write. I couldn't stay, not with Corrinford's PENDING pile three weeks away and growing, and a hill I had promised to climb.

So we did what you do when you can't keep a promise properly: we made a smaller one we could.

The new sign went up beside the old one on the morning of Day 250. This door opens on run days, every six weeks, when the keeper or her partner comes down with the escort. On those days you may draw any coin you like, in full. Between those days, your coin is behind two locks. Ask Wat. He cannot read this, but he knows what it says.

Wat kept his key. Lotte's went into Corvin's satchel, on a cord, next to the blank brass stamp and Anselm's correction. Nobody would open that vault now except with Wat standing beside them.

Lotte herself went to Gil Harker's warehouse on the wharf, to wait for the magistrate. Gil had offered her a corner of the loft above the rope store. He had been very angry about it.

"I've been lied to by better than you, girl," he roared, in front of the whole wharf, "and not one of them ever said sorry, so you can sleep in my loft and eat my onions until they decide what's to be done with you, and I don't want to hear another word about it."

Lotte didn't say another word about it. She stood on the wharf with her writing board under her arm, and her kerchief back on, and her face doing nothing at all, and watched us go.

I didn't look back. If I had, I think my face might finally have done something, and I still didn't know what.


Fenn was on the step again when the cart came down to the bridge on Day 274. He ran the length of the bridge, the way he had the last time, and stopped in front of me, and held up all ten fingers five times over, and then two more.

"Fifty-two days," he said. "You didn't even say a number this time."

"No," I said. "I didn't."

Fenn thought about this with a face like thunder.

"That's worse," he said.

Brenna didn't say anything at all. She put a honey bun in my hand, and another in Corvin's, and a third in Tamsin's, and counted them as she did it, out loud, so that I would know she had. Then she went back inside, and I heard her start to knead something very hard.

I didn't go in. I gave Fenn my bag, and went straight up the hill.

It had become steeper since the last time. I am almost sure of it. Corvin walked beside me the whole way and didn't say anything, and at the iron gate he stopped, and so did I, because Mistress Hale was already standing on the other side of it, with the gate open.

I have begun to suspect that she lives behind it.

Aldous was in his chair in the study, with his bandaged foot on its stool. He did not take his spectacles off when I came in. That was the first thing I noticed. The second was that his rings were all on his fingers. None of them were holding anything down.

"Sit," he said.

I didn't. I stood in front of his desk with my hands folded and told it all again, the way I had told it to Anselm. In order. With dates. Without adjectives. The thirteen accounts from down the road, and the fourteen rows. The count at dawn. The revoked stamp. The steward in the Watch's cells. The eleven depositors paid in full and gone, the twenty-two who stayed, the sign on the door, and the smaller promise we had made instead of the large one we couldn't keep.

When I had finished, Aldous asked me the two questions he had sent me away with, in exactly the same thin, dry voice.

"How much of it was my money?"

"All of it, Master Penhallow," I said. "Every bit of the loss comes out of your capital. Every depositor has been paid, or can be, in full." I didn't look away from his pale eyes. "Three hundred crowns, the day we signed. Two hundred and forty-five crowns and eight marks tonight."

"And whose fault?"

"Mine."

"I said that I would decide that." He turned one of his rings, slowly, all the way round, and then the next one. "So I have. It is yours, for choosing her. It is mine, for paying for a vault in a city I'll never see and never once asking who would be standing beside it." His eyes went past me, to the doorway, where Corvin stood very straight, with his satchel held against his chest. "And it is yours, Dalle. You counted that house thirty-six days after the first false row was written. Thirty-six."

"Yes, Master Penhallow," said Corvin.

He didn't argue. He didn't explain about three weeks of road, or the tidiest book he had ever read. He just stood there and let it land. I have never respected anyone more than I did him in that moment, and I have never wanted so badly to argue on someone else's behalf.

Don't, I told myself. He doesn't want you to. That's the point. He's letting it be his.

Aldous looked at us both for a long time.

"When we signed," he said, "you told me that if this house failed, it would be my capital that paid. I told you I had risked more on worse." He took his spectacles off at last and pressed his thumb and finger against his eyes. "I find, tonight, that I don't much enjoy being made a liar by my own words."

"I'm sorry, Master Penhallow."

"I know you are. That is not a sum." He put the spectacles back on. "The season ends tomorrow. You have forty days from tonight. Then I'll decide whether my capital stays in this house."

Mistress Hale walked us back to the gate. She didn't say anything on the way. At the gate she held it open, and as I went through, she said, so quietly that I nearly didn't hear it:

"He hasn't slept since your row came."

I walked down the hill in the dark. It was not, I noticed, any less steep going down.


Brenna was waiting on the step at dawn on Day 275, the last day of the season, in her good grey shawl, with a twist of cloth in her floury fist. Her second installment wasn't due until the evening bell. She had been sitting there, Fenn told me later, since before the bread went in.

"One crown, seven marks, four bits," she said, before I had the bar off the door. "Counted twice."

Corvin counted it twice again, out loud. I wrote the row in her loan book and stamped it, and the gold ran, and Brenna watched it go with her arms folded, the way she watches a loaf she has decided not to trust until it is out of the oven.

"Second," she said.

"Second, Mistress Holt. On time."

"Early," said Brenna. "It's not dark yet." She tucked the loan book into her apron, against her chest, and looked at me hard. "You look worse than yesterday."

"Thank you, Mistress Holt."

"Eat something," said Brenna, and went back across the bridge to put the bread in.

Somewhere down the road, I thought, a baron who owes everyone between his fences and this bridge is sitting down to his breakfast. And here is a baker who once kept her whole life under a floorboard, paying for her roof before dark. I had no idea yet how that thought would sound by the third bell.

The fruit basket arrived at the third bell on Day 275, and this time it came with its sender.

Master Hollis Grane took a token from the dish by the door. He looked at the number on it with polite interest, and joined the end of the queue, and waited his turn behind a carter and two of Hettie's girls, leaning lightly on his walking stick. He was exactly as I remembered him from the town hall: small and neat, with smooth silver hair combed back from a high forehead, a short silver beard, round gold-rimmed spectacles, and the gentle face of a schoolmaster who has never once had to raise his voice. The thin gold chain across his dark green coat had the same little brass scale hanging from it.

The basket was on his arm. It was even larger than the last one.

At home, I thought, watching him come down the line, men like this didn't queue. They got the priority lounge, and the good coffee, and a relationship manager who called them Bapak and asked after their grandchildren. And here he is, with token number thirty-one, waiting behind a carter.

That's worse. That is so much worse.

When his number came up, he set the basket on the oak in front of my window.

"Miss Halim." His voice was as soft as I remembered. "I was so very sorry to hear of your troubles in Aubrelle."

"Thank you, Master Grane," I said. "How did you hear of them?"

He smiled kindly. "Everybody hears everything in time. That is the trouble with paper. It does get about."

Behind me, I felt Corvin come out from behind his grille and stand very still. At the door, Borrik had already taken the basket off the counter, on the grounds that he was Head of Security and the fruit might be poisoned, and had begun testing it, one plum at a time, with great seriousness. By the end of the afternoon, there would be no evidence left at all.

"I wondered," said Master Grane, "whether you had heard the other news from down that road. Lord Crane has settled his account with the Brotherhood." He adjusted his spectacles with one finger. "At harvest's end. Forty-eight crowns, in good coin, by the hand of his steward. The first time in six years that his lordship has paid us anything at all." He paused, very slightly. "We were so pleased. And so surprised. One does wonder where he found it."

My face did nothing. I have never been so grateful to it.

Inside, something had gone perfectly cold and perfectly clear, the way a counter goes at the end of the day when the drawer is short and you finally understand by exactly how much, and exactly where it went.

Fifty crowns and seven marks went down that road in Gerrit Pask's pockets, I thought. And forty-eight came back to the Brotherhood. To him. To the house that took Aldous's brother's barges, thirty-one years ago.

Aldous's coin. In Grane's vault.

"Did you know where it came from, Master Grane?" I said.

"Coin, Miss Halim," said Hollis Grane gently, "has no memory. That is rather the point of it." He took up his walking stick. "I assure you, every figure in our books is correct."

Correct, I thought. They always say correct.

He turned to go. Then, as if he had just remembered something small, he turned back.

"Do give my regards to Master Penhallow," he said. "I understand he has had a difficult season. My father always spoke so warmly of his family."

He dropped his token back into the dish by the door, number facing up, and went out into the street.

Nobody in the hall said anything for a moment. Then Hettie Brook, who was fourth in line, said, "Well," very loudly, and the hall started breathing again.

Corvin was standing at my elbow. He didn't look at me. He was looking at the door.

"He wants you to tell Aldous," he said quietly.

"I know."

"If you tell him, it's the Brotherhood's coin now, and his brother's barges, and everything his family ever lost to that house, all of it on top of the fifty-four crowns." Corvin's voice was very level. "That's what he came for. Not to gloat. To put a wedge between Aldous and this house, and let you drive it in yourself."

"I know."

"If you don't tell him—"

"Then Grane tells him," I said. "Next week, or next season, in a note with a fruit basket. And Aldous finds out I knew, and didn't say." I picked up my pen. My hand was perfectly steady. I checked. "And then there's nothing left to save."

Corvin looked at me then, for a long moment.

"Will you?"

"Tonight," I said.

Borrik, by the door, finished the last plum, considered the empty basket with deep suspicion, and pronounced the whole thing safe.


The hill had not become any less steep since the night before. If anything, it had been working on it.

Mistress Hale opened the iron gate before I reached it. I no longer suspect that she lives behind it. I know.

Aldous was where I had left him, in his chair, with his foot on its stool and a cup of something gone cold at his elbow. He looked at me over his spectacles when I came in, and for a moment something crossed his sharp old face that I can only call dread.

"Twice in two days," he said. "Sit down, Miss Halim. Whatever it is, I'd rather not look up at it."

So I sat.

I told him about the fruit basket, and the token, and the forty-eight crowns in good coin by the hand of the steward, at harvest's end, the first in six years. I told him what Master Grane had said about coin having no memory. I told him the last thing too, word for word, because it was his to hear and not mine to soften.

Do give my regards to Master Penhallow. My father always spoke so warmly of his family.

Aldous didn't move.

The fire ticked. The clock I had noticed the last time went on counting somewhere in the house. Mistress Hale, by the door, did not breathe, as far as I could tell.

"Forty crowns," said Aldous at last.

I waited.

"That was the debt. Thirty-one years ago. My brother Edric borrowed forty crowns from Matthias Grane to mend a hull, at a fifth a month, and by the end of the year Matthias Grane owned all three of his barges, and Edric owned a cup." He turned his heavy gold ring, slowly. "He went on owning cups for eleven more years. Then he didn't need them any more."

"I'm sorry, Master Penhallow."

"You keep saying that." He didn't say it unkindly. "Grane sent you up this hill to tell me this."

"Yes."

"You knew he had."

"Yes."

"And you came anyway."

"It's your money," I said. "You have a right to know where it went. And you'd have found out. Next week, or next season, in a note with a fruit basket. And then you'd have found out I knew."

Aldous Penhallow looked at me for a very long time. I had the feeling, the one I sometimes have at the counter with an old customer, that he was not looking at my face at all, because he had long ago learned there was nothing to find there. He was looking at the fact that I was sitting in his chair, in his study, at night, for the second time in two days, telling him the thing that made him like me less.

"When Edric went under," he said slowly, "nobody came up any hill to tell him anything. They let him find out at the wharf, in front of everyone, when the Brotherhood's men came for the barges." He took his spectacles off. "I have not forgotten that."

He put them on the desk, very carefully, side by side with his cold cup.

"Here are my terms," said Aldous. "You have thirty-nine days. Before they are out, you will bring me a house in which no single hand, however honest, however kind, however much you like the look of it, can write a lie into my books and have it turn to gold. Not two keys on a vault. Two keys on a vault did nothing. A house." His thin, dry voice didn't rise at all. "Show me that, and my capital stays, and your Aubrelle door may open again. Show me less, and you will close it, and I will take what is left of my money home, and put it in a tin."

I thought of my mother's biscuit tin, behind the rice in 1997.

"Yes, Master Penhallow," I said.

"Go home. Sleep. You look like a ledger somebody has been crying on."

Mistress Hale walked me to the gate with a lantern. At the gate she stopped, and held it up, so that the light fell on my face. I don't know what she saw there. Probably nothing. Most people do.

"He keeps his passbook on his desk," she said. "The one-crown one. From the morning of your run." She lowered the lantern. "He has not put it away."

Then she gave me the lantern, and closed the gate, and went back up the path to the honey-colored house, very straight, without looking round.

I wrote my closing at the counter, with the bar across the door and Corvin at his grille, because I didn't want to write it anywhere else.

Day 275. Season closed. Capital: 245 crowns, 8 marks. Aldous's days: 39. Depositors: 212. Real: 199.

I looked at the last number for a long time.

One short, I thought. The whole season, and it closed one short. After everything. One.

Corvin read it over my shoulder. He held out his hand for my pen, and I gave it to him. He clicked it four times, very slowly, and wrote one line underneath, in his cramped, ink-stained hand.

Two hands on every row. (C.D.)

"What does that mean?" I said.

"It means," said Corvin, giving me back my pen, "that I have thirty-nine days to explain it to Aldous Penhallow without boxes."

He looked, for the first time since Aubrelle, very nearly happy about something.

நீங்கள் விரும்பிய பகுதிகளை ஆர்ப்பரிக்க ஒரு பத்தியைத் தட்டவும்.

நீங்கள் என்ன நினைக்கிறீர்கள்?

ஆர்ப்பரிக்க உள்நுழையவும்

இந்த அத்தியாயம் எப்படி இருந்தது?

உள்நுழையவும் மதிப்புரை எழுதவும்.

விமர்சனங்கள்

இன்னும் விமர்சனங்கள் இல்லை. முதலில் எழுதுங்கள்.

அத் 10அத் 12