I cut keys. Three generations of the trade, and my grandfather's bench is still bolted to the floor under mine, with the shape of his knees worn into the wood. I notice wear. Noticing wear is the whole job.
A key is a confession. You can read a man off the one in his hand. Which side he presses with his thumb. Whether the teeth are polished bright or gone gray and soft at the tips. Whether he keeps it on a ring with forty others because he is afraid of losing things, or alone on a bare ring because he isn't. I have cut keys for every house in this county and opened most of them myself, at night, when somebody is locked out and ashamed to have called me.
So when he came in, I read him the way I read everyone, and got nothing to hang it on. He stood on my mat dripping. He did not shake the rain off. He took a key out of his coat and laid it on the counter like a man laying down a thing he is done carrying, and it was the strangest key I have handled in thirty years of handling keys.
It was brass worn to a sliver. No cuts left. Just a blank with the memory of teeth in it, the ghost of a shape you could almost read if the light was right, which it never is.
I said, what does it open.
He said he didn't remember. He said he lost the door.
I told him there was nothing left to copy. A key that worn has been turned ten thousand times by a hand that knew it, and every turn takes a little off it, and what he had was the last of it, the spent end. I said if he had the lock I could make one to fit it. He said if he had the lock he wouldn't need the key.
I took it anyway. I don't know why. I told him a day.
That night I sat with it under the lamps and tried to read it. You read a worn key by what's left: the shoulders, the depth of the last cut, the way the brass has thinned on the side the thumb lived. There was a shape in it, and I cut to it, and I did it the way I have cut ten thousand keys, by trust. Then I stood in my shop with a new key in my hand and no lock in the world to test it on, which had never happened to me. Every key I make, I test. A key that opens nothing is a coin.
I put the dead one in the drawer with the unclaimed. That drawer is a kind of graveyard and I keep it for the town's sake. Keys to houses that got rekeyed after a divorce. Keys to a storefront that burned. Keys people dropped in the street and never came back for, because a lost key is a thing you can convince yourself is fine. I have never been able to throw a key away. Ask me why and I'll tell you it's bad luck. It isn't.
Here is what I understood, over the weeks after, and I want to set it down plain.
Everybody locks something. The rich lock everything and sleep fine. The poor lock one door and check it twice. The honest lock nothing, and it doesn't matter, because nobody is coming. Everyone who ever called me at three in the morning had already decided, without saying so, that there was a thing worth keeping, and had spent their whole life keeping it. That's the whole of us. That's every brass confession on my wall.
He had nothing shut. No door on him at all. I don't mean he was open the way a trusting man is open. I mean there was nothing there to lock, because there was nothing he was keeping. You cannot cut a key to a man with nothing to protect. There's no shape to read. There's no thumb, there's no side the brass has worn against, because nothing ever held him long enough to wear.
I made the false key anyway. I finished it. I carried it in my coat pocket for a month waiting for him to come and claim the real one, and he never came, and one morning I found I'd stopped feeling for it and started being able to lose it, and that frightened me more than it should have.
I still have the dead key. It's in the drawer with the unclaimed, which is where the keys of things nobody's looking for go, and I open that drawer less than I used to. I'm the only woman in this county who can get into anybody's house, and I have a drawer full of doors I can't find, and one of them had a man behind it who spent himself down to a sliver trying to get back to it.
A key is two things. What it lets in, and what it keeps out, and everybody I've ever cut for wanted the second one. He wanted the first one, and there was nothing on the far side, and he'd already turned himself smooth trying.